CONGENITAL HEART DISEASE

Surgical and transcatheter (Amplatzer) closure of atrial septal defects: a prospective comparison of results and cost

J D R Thomson, E H Aburawi, K G Watterson, C Van Doorn, J L Gibbs

Department of Paediatric Cardiology and Cardiac Surgery, The Yorkshire Heart Centre, Leeds General Infirmary, Great George St, Leeds LS1 3EX, UK

Correspondence to:
Correspondence to:
Dr J D R Thomson, Department of Paediatric Cardiology, E floor, Jubilee Wing, Leeds General Infirmary, Great George St, Leeds LS1 3EX, UK;
john.thomson{at}lineone.net

Objective: To compare effectiveness, complications, and cost of Amplatzer with surgical atrial septal defect (ASD) closure.

Design: Prospective study.

Setting: Tertiary cardiac referral centre.

Patients: 43 consecutive patients (excluding non-UK residents) aged between 2.1 and 56.8 years (median 7) undergoing ASD closure.

Main outcome measures: Procedural success, complications, regression of right ventricular dilatation (up to one year postprocedure), cost, inpatient stay, and home convalescent time.

Results: Amplatzer ASD closure was successful in 24 of 27 (89%) patients. Surgical closure was successful in all 19 cases. Cardiac complications affecting management occurred in three (11%) of the Amplatzer group (two procedural failures, one device embolisation) and 4 of 19 (21%) surgical patients (one pericardial pain, one global pericardial effusion requiring drainage, and one patient with anaemia requiring haematinics in addition to an incidental pericardial effusion and one further incidental pericardial effusion) (p = NS). There were complications that did not affect management in a further 5 of 19 surgical patients. There was no significant difference in regression of right ventricular dilatation by six months postprocedure (median right ventricular end diastolic diameter decrease: Amplatzer group 17.5%, surgical group 15.1%; median cardiothoracic ratio decrease: Amplatzer 7.9%, surgical 7.5%). Both hospital stay and home convalescent times were significantly shorter after Amplatzer closure (median hospital stay: Amplatzer one day, surgery six days; median convalescent time: Amplatzer two weeks, surgery 5.5 weeks). Median cost was similar for both groups (Amplatzer £5375, surgical £5412).

Conclusions: Amplatzer ASD closure has a lower chance of success with a single procedure than surgery. Overall, there were more complications in the surgical group but the majority of these were minor and did not require any change in management. Resolution of right ventricular dilatation over the study period was similar for both techniques. Time spent in hospital and away from work or school was shorter for the Amplatzer group. The cost of both techniques was similar.

Keywords: Amplatzer; atrial septal defect

Abbreviations: ASD, atrial septal defect; RVEDD, right ventricular end diastolic diameter

CiteULike    Complore    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    Technorati    What's this?

This article has been cited by other articles:

• Dave, H. H., Comber, M., Solinger, T., Bettex, D., Dodge-Khatami, A., Pretre, R. (2009). Mid-term results of right axillary incision for the repair of a wide range of congenital cardiac defects. Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg. 35: 864-870 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Tao, K.-y., An, Q., Gan, C.-p., Tang, H., Feng, Y., Song, H.-b. (2009). Give the patient another chance: Peratrial device closure of a secundum atrial septal defect that failed percutaneous device closure. J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg. 137: 1024-1027 [Full Text]  
• Gaca, A. M., Jaggers, J. J., Dudley, L. T., Bisset, G. S. III (2008). Repair of Congenital Heart Disease: A Primer--Part 2. Radiology 248: 44-60 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Ak, K., Aybek, T., Wimmer-Greinecker, G., Ozaslan, F., Bakhtiary, F., Moritz, A., Dogan, S. (2007). Evolution of surgical techniques for atrial septal defect repair in adults: A 10-year single-institution experience. J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg. 134: 757-764 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Contrafouris, C. A., Chatzis, A. C., Giannopoulos, N. M., Milonakis, M., Kousi, T., Kirvassilis, G., Sarris, G. E. (2006). Emergency surgical intervention for runaway atrial septal defect closure devices: A word of caution.. J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg. 132: 1234-1235 [Full Text]  
• Hanslik, A., Pospisil, U., Salzer-Muhar, U., Greber-Platzer, S., Male, C. (2006). Predictors of Spontaneous Closure of Isolated Secundum Atrial Septal Defect in Children: A Longitudinal Study. Pediatrics 118: 1560-1565 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Santoro, G, Pascotto, M, Caputo, S, Cerrato, F, Cappelli Bigazzi, M, Palladino, M T, Iacono, C, Carrozza, M, Russo, M G, Calabro, R (2006). Similar cardiac remodelling after transcatheter atrial septal defect closure in children and young adults. Heart 92: 958-962 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Schoen, S P, Kittner, T, Bohl, S, Braun, M U, Simonis, G, Schmeisser, A, Strasser, R H (2006). Transcatheter closure of atrial septal defects improves right ventricular volume, mass, function, pulmonary pressure, and functional class: a magnetic resonance imaging study. Heart 92: 821-826 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Vida, V. L., Barnoya, J., O'Connell, M., Leon-Wyss, J., Larrazabal, L. A., Castaneda, A. R. (2006). Surgical Versus Percutaneous Occlusion of Ostium Secundum Atrial Septal Defects: Results and Cost-Effective Considerations in a Low-Income Country. J Am Coll Cardiol 47: 326-331 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Pawelec-Wojtalik, M., Wojtalik, M., Mrowczynski, W., Surmacz, R., Quereshi, S. A. (2006). Comparison of cardiac function in children after surgical and Amplatzer occluder closure of secundum atrial septal defects. Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg. 29: 89-92 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Pretre, R., Kadner, A., Dave, H., Dodge-Khatami, A., Bettex, D., Berger, F. (2005). Right axillary incision: A cosmetically superior approach to repair a wide range of congenital cardiac defects. J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg. 130: 277-281 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Hopkins, R. A., Bert, A. A., Buchholz, B., Guarino, K., Meyers, M. (2004). Surgical patch closure of atrial septal defects. Ann. Thorac. Surg. 77: 2144-2149 [Abstract] [Full Text]  
• Suematsu, Y., Takamoto, S., Kaneko, Y., Ohtsuka, T., Takayama, H., Kotsuka, Y., Murakami, A. (2003). Beating Atrial Septal Defect Closure Monitored by Epicardial Real-Time Three-Dimensional Echocardiography Without Cardiopulmonary Bypass. Circulation 107: 785-790 [Abstract] [Full Text]