Article Text

PDF

Why patients do not attend cardiac rehabilitation: role of intentions and illness beliefs

Abstract

OBJECTIVE Many patients fail to attend cardiac rehabilitation. Attempts to identify sociodemographic or clinical predictors of non-attendance have not been very successful; therfore, this study aimed to determine whether the illness beliefs held during hospitalisation by patients who had suffered acute myocardial infarction or who had undergone coronary artery bypass graft surgery could predict cardiac rehabilitation attendance.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS 152 patients were prospectively studied of whom 41% had attended cardiac rehabilitation at six months.

RESULTS In addition to being older, less aware of their cholesterol values, and less likely to be employed, non-attenders were less likely to believe their condition was controllable and that their lifestyle may have contributed to their illness.

CONCLUSION It should now be determined whether interventions aimed at optimising certain perceptions could promote cardiac rehabilitation uptake among those patients who could benefit the most.

  • rehabilitation
  • myocardial infarction
  • coronary artery bypass graft surgery
  • illness beliefs

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Despite the established benefits of cardiac rehabilitation1-4many patients either decline to attend or adhere poorly to courses. Petrie et al found that only a third of eligible patients under 65 years old attended cardiac rehabilitation,5 and Ades et alshowed uptake as low as 21% in eligible patients over 62 years.6 The American Heart Association7 has emphasised the need to identify and focus on patients whose medical and social profiles predict non-compliance, since these patients may benefit most from specific interventions.

Not only are biological and sociodemographic characteristics inconsistently associated with non-attendance, the value of these as predictors is questionable given that they are not usually amenable to change. In contrast, individual’s beliefs or perceptions about their illness appear to play a pivotal role in health behaviour including medication adherence,8 and functional status.9 10 Furthermore a recent study emphasised the role of illness perceptions in predicting rehabilitation attendance, return to work, and physical functioning following acute myocardial infarction.5

The recently developed illness perception questionnaire (IPQ) is a validated measurement tool used by health psychologists to assess patients’ beliefs about their illness.11 It has been established that beliefs are organised around straightforward and self explanatory central themes or components. These are referred to as “common sense illness representations”12 and are hypothesised to explain variations in the way patients respond to their illness (table1).

Table 1

Explanation of core illness beliefs

We set out to determine whether the beliefs held during hospitalisation by patients who had suffered acute myocardial infarction or who had undergone coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABG) could predict cardiac rehabilitation attendance. The potential differences in illness beliefs between these two patient groups was also explored.

Methods

DESIGN AND PATIENT POPULATION

We conducted a prospective study involving 152 patients hospitalised for acute myocardial infarction or CABG. Consecutive patients were recruited to complete a questionnaire independently before discharge. Postal or telephone follow up assessed cardiac rehabilitation attendance at six months.

Patients who suffered acute myocardial infarction at two district general hospitals and patients having CABG on the cardiothoracic ward at Guy’s Hospital, London were enrolled. No exclusion criteria were set.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS

A binary and ordinal response questionnaire covering five areas was developed, details of which are listed in table 2. Not all patients answered every question. Thus the figures given for certain items do not total 137 but reflect the number who responded to that item.

Table 2

Main variables recorded by questionnaire

STATISTICAL ANALYSIS

SPSS for Windows 6.0 statistical software package was used throughout. Multiscore items of the IPQ were treated as continuous data and thus were analysed parametrically, using one way analysis of variance (ANOVA). Single item scores (causal attribution to lifestyle/stress) were treated non-parametrically and analysed using Mann-Whitney U test. Frequency data were analysed using χ2 test. Variables predictive of cardiac rehabilitation attendance were analysed univariately to establish significant differences between attenders and non-attenders. Significant variables were entered into a forward stepwise logistic regression with attendance as the dependent variable.

Results

A total of 152 patients were recruited, with 15 exclusions as a result of four deaths and 11 uncompleted questionnaires. Summary patient baseline characteristics on the remaining 137 patients are shown in table 3. Not unexpectedly, those patients who had suffered acute myocardial infarction only were less likely to have a previous history of coronary artery disease than either CABG patients or those with both acute myocardial infarction and then CABG. Patients in the CABG and CABG/acute myocardial infarction group were more likely to be male and to state an awareness of their total cholesterol concentrations.

Table 3

Summary of patient baseline characteristics

Overall, 55 (40%) patients attended rehabilitation with 82 (60%) patients failing to attend by six months. There were no differences in illness perceptions or other sociodemographic variables between diagnostic groups (table 4) and all subjects were therefore combined to analyse potential differences between cardiac rehabilitation attenders and non-attenders. Table 5 shows the significant differences between the two groups; when these were entered into a logistic regression, age, perceptions of control, a causal attribution to lifestyle, and knowledge of total cholesterol concentration retained significance.

Table 4

Differences in illness perceptions and risk factors between diagnostic categories

Table 5

Differences in baseline variables between attenders and non-attenders

Discussion

Patients’ illness beliefs were not influenced according to whether they had undergone CABG or acute myocardial infarction. One reason may be that patients diagnosed with coronary heart disease may establish firm beliefs about their illness at an early stage, perhaps because of the dominant prevalence of coronary heart disease in our society. Patients may draw on beliefs based on knowledge gained through media coverage and the experience of friends or colleagues which remain fairly stable over the varying course of their illness.13

The rehabilitation attendance rate of 40% is comparable with that reported in other studies5 6 but falls short of the 72% of patients who expressed an intention to attend. The intention to attend rate in those actually attending cardiac rehabilitation was over 90% versus 58% for those not attending. This adds further weight to the evidence that intention alone is useful but not sufficient to predict future health behaviour.14 15

Reliable predictors of attendance behaviour during hospital admission are necessary in order to optimise uptake in those who could benefit the most. This study shows that patient illness perceptions measured during hospital admission are associated with future cardiac rehabilitation attendance and that those with a stronger belief that their condition is controllable will subsequently take appropriate action such as attendance at cardiac rehabilitation. Similarly, individuals who attributed their heart condition to their lifestyle showed a higher rate of cardiac rehabilitation attendance indicating that this particular causal belief is associated with a commitment to further behaviour change.5

It may seem incongruent that knowledge of one risk factor, cholesterol, is associated with attendance while another, blood pressure, is not. However, individuals may feel that a high cholesterol is more relevant to heart disease than high blood pressure, which is perhaps perceived as quite common within the general population. In addition, patients may consider themselves to have more control over their cholesterol via dietary changes.

Few studies have investigated predictors of cardiac rehabilitation attendance, especially in relation to illness perceptions. It is encouraging that these results confirm those of a study of first time acute myocardial infarction patients under 65 years old where patients with a perception that their condition was controllable or curable were more likely to attend rehabilitation.5 Patient age may influence cardiac rehabilitation attendance but the identification of predictive illness perceptions may permit their modification to improve overall attendance and optimise outcome.

The 1996 UK cardiac rehabilitation guidelines and audit standards emphasise the importance of “addressing patients’ main concerns and correcting misconceptions” throughout the rehabilitation phase from inhospital stay through to long term follow up.16 The IPQ could provide an ideal platform to determine an individual’s illness perceptions as a routine part of recovery assessment. Illness perceptions have been shown to be amenable to change10 17 18 in other illnesses; by providing information regarding illness perceptions in cardiac patients, simple individually structured interventions to address possible misconceptions could be developed. This may improve attendance in cardiac rehabilitation and additionally have a positive effect on other important outcome measures such as time to return to work and physical functioning.

Acknowledgments

We are grateful to all physiotherapy and cardiac rehabilitation staff , especially Jackie Anderson, Lesley Brooks, Sarah Deacon, Gilly Fumicelli, Sam Healy, Lynn Kilner, Lynne Schofield, Sally Stone, and Kate Street, for their enthusiastic help with this study.

References

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.