Article Text


Repolarisation and refractoriness during early ischaemia in humans


OBJECTIVES To determine whether effective refractory period (ERP) shortens or lengthens in the first minutes of ischaemia in humans, and the relation between ERP changes and action potential duration (APD).

METHODS ERP and monophasic action potential duration (MAPD) were measured from a single left ventricular epicardial site in 26 patients undergoing coronary artery surgery. Cardiopulmonary bypass was instituted and normothermia maintained. Refractory period was determined by the extrastimulus technique at a basic cycle length of 500 ms, at four times (group 1, 15 patients) or two times (group 2, 11 patients) the preischaemic diastolic threshold. A three minute period of ischaemia was instituted by aortic cross clamping between the input from the pump oxygenator and the heart.

RESULTS After three minutes of ischaemia, mean (SEM) ERP lengthened from 232 (5) ms (control) to 246 (7) ms (p < 0.005) in group 1, and from 256 (10) ms (control) to 348 (25) ms (p < 0.005) in group 2. In the same time MAPD shortened from 256 (5) ms (control) to 189 (9) ms (p < 0.001) with no difference between groups. Thus postrepolarisation refractoriness developed during ischaemia. Before ischaemia, ERP showed a good correlation with APD (R 2 = 0.64) but by one minute of ischaemia the correlation was poor (R 2 = 0.29).

CONCLUSIONS These results show that during the first three minutes of global ischaemia in patients with coronary artery disease: (1) ERP lengthened in response to both a low and a high stimulus strength; and (2) there was a good correlation between ERP and APD before ischaemia, which was lost by one minute as APD decreased and ERP increased. These findings may have important implications in arrhythmogenesis.

  • refractoriness
  • ischaemia
  • repolarisation

Statistics from

Extensive experimental evidence implicates enhanced dispersion of refractoriness with arrhythmogenesis.1 2 A short refractory period interposed between regions of longer refractory period facilitates the formation of re-entrant circuits.3 Under normal conditions the refractory period is predominantly voltage dependent and ends at full repolarisation of the action potential.4 On this basis a common antiarrhythmic strategy is the use of drugs which prolong action potential duration (APD), with the intention of prolonging refractoriness and so reducing the likelihood of re-entry.5 APD is widely used as a measure of refractoriness in studies related to mechanisms of arrhythmogenesis. However, experimental studies have shown that after the first few minutes of ischaemia the refractory period changes from being mainly voltage dependent to being mainly time dependent—that is, independent of APD.6-11 This transition is relevant clinically, as the majority of serious ventricular arrhythmias during ischaemia are caused by re-entry and occur within the first minutes of onset.3 Information in humans is lacking. Extrapolation of experimental work on ischaemia induced changes in refractoriness is difficult because reports include a shortening,1 12-18 a lengthening,12 19-21 a lengthening followed by a shortening,22 23 or a shortening followed by a lengthening.9 22 24 25 It is likely that at least some of these differences relate to methodological factors. These include the stimulus strength used in relation to the activation threshold, which increases progressively during early ischaemia,12and the use of very strong stimuli which may excite fibres distant from the stimulation site.20 The presence or absence of residual perfusion (for example low flow ischaemia) or of diffusion across border zones between ischaemic and non-ischaemic regions may also be a factor.26 Extrapolation to the clinical situation is further hindered by the known electrophysiological species differences and a lack of comparative information between different animal models and patients with long standing coronary artery disease. The present study attempts to address some of these difficulties. We have performed studies directly in patients with chronic heart disease, used global ischaemia which eliminates border zones, and incorporated high and low pacing stimulus strengths. We sought answers to the following questions. First, in the initial few minutes of ischaemia in these patients, does the effective refractory period lengthen or shorten? Second, what is the relation of this change to APD?



We studied 26 patients (22 men and four women) aged 33–76 years (mean 63 years). All were undergoing routine coronary artery surgery for the relief of angina. Patients were selected at random. Patients taking cardioactive drugs other than β blockers, calcium antagonists, and angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors were excluded. The study protocol was approved by the hospital ethics committee, and written informed consent was obtained from each patient.


The monophasic action potential (MAP) provides a faithful representation of the time course of the transmembrane potential,27-29 and is an established and widely used technique for investigating the in situ beating heart. Reliable recordings may be obtained on the human epicardium.30 31We recorded an MAP using a pressure contact electrode from the anterior left ventricular epicardium. The MAP signals were fed to a Gould isolated preamplifier (model 11-5407-58) (Gould Electronics, Ilford, Essex, UK) to provide patient isolation and then to a Gould Universal amplifier (model 13-4615-58; input impedance 109 ohms) with an output of 2.5 V for 40 mV input. MAP signals were filtered from dc to 100 MHz . Data were digitised at a sampling rate of 1 kHz (CED 1401 plus, Cambridge Electronic Design, Cambridge, UK) and stored.


Patients were studied in two groups. There was no difference between the groups with respect to age, drug treatment, or number of coronary arteries with significant disease. Steady state cathodal pacing (2 ms current pulses, cycle length of 500 ms) was established using a UHS 20 stimulator (Biotronik, Oxfordshire, UK). The pacing electrode was positioned on the left ventricular epicardium immediately adjacent to the MAP recording site, the rib spreaders acting as the anode. Stimulus strength was set at four times control diastolic threshold in one group of patients (group 1) and at two times control diastolic threshold in a second group of patients (group 2), and maintained at these (preischaemic) levels throughout the test period. Effective refractory period (ERP) was determined using the extrastimulus technique by decrementing a test pulse (S2) interval by 10 ms after each ninth basic beat (S1) until S2 did not result in an action potential or an ECG waveform. ERP was taken as the shortest possible S1–S2 interval that produced a propagated response.


Following the initiation of cardiopulmonary bypass and before revascularisation surgery, the electrodes were positioned, diastolic threshold determined, and electrophysiological measurements made. Normothermia was maintained. The cardiac surgeon routinely uses cross clamp fibrillation for the graft anastomoses. This involves clamping the ascending aorta between the inflow from the pump oxygenator and the heart. It has been shown that the resulting short period of ischaemia followed by reflow before the grafting induces a preconditioning effect and so is protective during the subsequent longer periods of ischaemia required for the graft procedures.32 We therefore used a three minute period of preconditioning ischaemia to measure the changes in refractory period and APD. After three minutes the cross clamp was released and pacing discontinued, following which routine surgery proceeded.


MAP signals were measured using an interactive computer program, and measurements of APD were made at 90% repolarisation. This allowed a visual inspection of the computer measurements for each complex measured. Statistical evaluation used analysis of variance with Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons (SPSS statistical package). Data are given as mean (SEM).


Figure 1 shows MAP recordings illustrating several features of the effects of ischaemia on APD and ERP. Recordings before ischaemia are shown in the upper panel. The top left pair of MAP signals is the last of an S1 train followed by the test action potential at the shortest S1–S2 coupling interval (250 ms) which elicited a propagated action potential. The top right MAP is the last S1 action potential at a shorter S1–S2 interval (240 ms) which fails to elicit an action potential. The refractory period is therefore 250 ms. The effect of ischaemia is shown in a similar format in the lower panel. The last S1 APD had shortened (from 262 ms to 230 ms) while the shortest S1–S2 interval at which a propagated action potential could be achieved was now longer (280 ms). The “take off” of the test action potential following the S2 stimulus during control occurred before final repolarisation of the S1 action potential (top left). During ischaemia the test action potential upstroke occurred after full repolarisation owing to postrepolarisation refractoriness (bottom right).

Figure 1

Monophasic action potential (MAP) recordings (last S1 and S2) during control (top) and ischaemia (below). The single MAPs on the right show the last MAP in the subsequent S1 train in which the S1–S2 interval is 10 ms shorter and S2 is unable to elicit a response. During ischaemia effective refractory period becomes longer than control and a gap is present between the repolarisation of the steady state beat (S1) and depolarisation of the premature beat (S2).


In all patients studied, MAP duration at 90% repolarisation (MAPD90) shortened during ischaemia. Mean values for all patients were 256 (5) ms (control), 231 (6) ms (p < 0.001) at one minute, 209 (8) ms at two minutes (p < 0.001), and 189 (9) ms (p < 0.001) at three minutes of ischaemia. Figure 2 shows that the values for group 1 patients (high stimulus strength) do not differ from those in group 2 patients (low stimulus strength).

Figure 2

Monophasic action potential at 90% repolarisation (MAPD90) of the left ventricular epicardium in patients with coronary artery disease during control conditions and after one, two, and three minutes of ischaemia (cycle length 500 ms). Values are shown separately for group 1, paced at four times preischaemic diastolic threshold, and group 2, paced at two times preischaemic diastolic threshold. Action potential duration (APD) shortened progressively during ischaemia. Values are means, error bars = SEM.


In contrast to the MAPD shortening, ERP increased at both stimulus strengths. Figure 3 shows mean values increasing from 232 (5) ms (control) to 245 (4) ms (p < 0.001), to 248 (7) ms (p < 0.015), and to 246 (7) ms (p < 0.05) in group 1, and from 256 (10) ms (control) to 278 (14) ms (p < 0.05), to 308 (18) ms (p < 0.01), and to 348 (25) ms (p < 0.005) in group 2, after one, two, and three minutes of ischaemia, respectively. The increase in refractory period was significant from one minute of ischaemia onwards for both groups.

Figure 3

Effective refractory period (ERP) on the left ventricular epicardium in patients with coronary artery disease during control conditions and after one, two, and three minutes of ischaemia. Mean values for ERP showed a small increase during ischaemia in group 1 (high pacing stimulus) and a substantial increase in group 2 (low pacing stimulus). Values are means, error bars = SEM.


Before ischaemia ERP was shorter than APD. Figure 4 (left) shows that the difference between ERP and APD was −20 (5) ms for group 1 and −8 (3) ms for group 2. During ischaemia this relation reversed, with ERP becoming longer than APD: 10 (7) ms (group 1) and 41 (9) ms (group 2) at one minute of ischaemia; 35 (7) ms (group 1) and 92 (14) ms (group 2) at two minutes; and 48 (9) ms (group 1) and 137 (19) ms (group 2) at three minutes (p < 0.001 at all time points for both groups). The development of postrepolarisation refractoriness reflected the combined effect of APD shortening (fig 2) and ERP lengthening (fig 3). The latter was more pronounced in group 2 patients. During control the relation between ERP and APD showed a good correlation (R 2 = 0.64, p < 0.001), which was lost in the course of ischaemia (R 2 = 0.29, p < 0.01;R 2 = 0.27, p < 0.02; andR 2 = 0.13, p < 0.14 at one, two, and three minutes, respectively).

Figure 4

The relation between action potential duration (APD) and refractoriness is shown as effective refractory period (ERP) minus APD for group 1 and group 2 patients. Under control conditions ERP was shorter than APD. During ischaemia this relation rapidly reversed, ERP outlasting APD (postrepolarisation refractoriness). This effect is more pronounced in group 2 patients (low stimulus strength).


We found that ERP lengthened during a short period of global ischaemia in the human heart following pacing with high and low stimulus strength. The high stimulus strength resulted in less ERP prolongation. It is known that refractoriness depends on APD and becomes dissociated from it during ischaemia.6-11 We therefore investigated the relation between ERP and APD in the human heart. Under control conditions ERP approximated MAPD, and there was a good correlation between the two. During ischaemia MAPD shortened while ERP increased, resulting in postrepolarisation refractoriness from the first minute of ischaemia onward.

Previous studies on ischaemia induced changes reported lengthening12 19-21 or shortening1 12-18of refractoriness. These differences may relate to methodological aspects of ERP measurement in ischaemia. Indeed, in dogs ERP either lengthened or shortened depending on the stimulus intensity.12 During ischaemia, stimulus threshold increases following an initial decrease12 20 33depending on the site of stimulation relative to the ischaemic border.33 Thus most investigators use a fixed stimulus strength ranging from twice to 15 times diastolic threshold.15 However, in regional ischaemia high intensity stimulation may inadvertently excite distant myocardium where ERP is shorter and excitability is increased.20 21 33 We therefore chose a model of global ischaemia, where border zone related phenomena are absent, and used two stimulus strengths. In humans ERP prolongation occurred over a wide range of stimulus strength.

Postrepolarisation refractoriness occurs in various models of ischaemia,6-11 although it has hitherto not been described in humans. It is caused by the combined effects of hypoxia and the accumulation of extracellular potassium (Ko).11 34 35 In border zone tissue where the rise in Ko is moderate,36 refractory periods shorten.20 21 37 In the centre of the ischaemic area Ko is similar to that found in global ischaemia.26 The resting membrane potential38and the recovery of excitability7 show a corresponding gradient from the periphery to the centre. Thus we speculate that the factors that influence Ko, such as diffusion and residual perfusion during low flow ischaemia,39 would influence ERP and the relation of ERP to APD. This may result in local ERP differences.

The observed changes in MAPD and refractoriness in response to ischaemia show a much faster time course in patients (with ischaemic heart disease) than in experimental animals.40 This highlights the importance of performing these studies directly in patients. Some aspects of methodology require mention. Our observations on MAPD/ERP were confined to a single left ventricular site in each patient. MAPD varies at different ventricular sites41 42and the effects of ischaemia are heterogeneous26 as well. However, our study employed global ischaemia which substantially reduces heterogeneity, and the recording sites were selected randomly on the left ventricular anterior wall, with consistent findings within each group. Also, the patients were on cardiopulmonary bypass and therefore the hearts were in a non-working state. This would have reduced the ischaemic burden and the influence of mechanoelectric feedback.31 As anticipated from the small heterogeneity, no arrhythmias occurred during ischaemia in these hearts.

This study examines one end of a spectrum of ischaemia—that is, zero perfusion/zero diffusion—in contrast to border zones of regional ischaemia or low flow ischaemia. Although extrapolation to the clinical setting requires caution, we would suggest that the results represent the central ischaemic zone where perfusion is absent and diffusion gradients are small.26

Mechanisms of arrhythmia are frequently interpreted and modelled using APD as a measure of ERP. Our results suggest that while the relation between APD and ERP may persist during early ischaemia in peripheral regions, ERP would be prolonged beyond repolarisation in central areas. These findings may be relevant to class III antiarrhythmic agents34 35 43 44 and APD alternans as precursor of ventricular fibrillation.45 46 Also, recent studies have centred on the role of the cycle length dependence of APD in the breakup of spiral waves into multiple wavelets characteristic of ventricular fibrillation.45-48 This has the potential for an alternative antiarrhythmic strategy, namely altering the slope of the APD/ERP relation.47 48 The early dissociation of APD and ERP within the first minutes of ischaemia, at a time when re-entrant arrhythmias develop, would be expected to alter the dynamics of the relation. Furthermore, our results and the above discussion suggest that this effect would be inhomogeneous.


This work was supported by the British Heart Foundation (PT).


View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.