Article Text


Long term cardiac follow up of severe twin to twin transfusion syndrome after intrauterine laser coagulation
  1. U Herberg1,
  2. W Gross1,
  3. P Bartmann2,
  4. C S Banek2,
  5. K Hecher3,
  6. J Breuer1
  1. 1Division of Paediatric Cardiology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany
  2. 2Division of Neonatology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany
  3. 3Department of Obstetrics and Fetal Medicine, University Clinic Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany
  1. Correspondence to:
    Dr Ulrike Herberg
    Division of Paediatric Cardiology, Children’s Hospital, University of Bonn, Adenauerallee 119, 53113 Bonn, Germany; Ulrike.Herberg{at}


Objective: To assess long term changes in cardiac morphology and function in survivors of severe twin to twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) after intrauterine laser coagulation of placental anastomoses.

Design: Prospective follow up of fetuses with severe TTTS treated by laser coagulation of intrauterine placental anastomoses. Fetal echocardiography and Doppler studies of feto-placental haemodynamic function were performed at the time of laser coagulation (median gestational age of 21.7 weeks). Postnatal cardiac follow up included a detailed echocardiographic study of systolic and diastolic cardiac function at a median age of 21.1 months.

Setting: Paediatric cardiology unit.

Patients: 89 survivors from 73 consecutive pregnancies with severe TTTS.

Results: Before laser treatment, 28 of 51 (54.9%) recipient twins had typical signs of cardiac dysfunction due to volume overload and 9 of 38 (23.7%) donors had absent or reversed end diastolic flow in the umbilical artery. Echocardiography was normal in 87.6% of the survivors (34 of 38 donors, 44 of 51 recipients). The prevalence of congenital heart disease and particularly of pulmonary stenosis, which was recorded only in recipients, was increased in comparison with the general population (congenital heart disease, 10 of 89 (11.2%) v 0.3%; pulmonary stenosis, 4 of 51 (7.8%) v 0.03%). Findings before laser treatment were not correlated with the development of structural heart disease.

Conclusions: Despite the high rate and severity of prenatal cardiac overload in recipients, the majority of cases of TTTS are normalised after laser treatment. However, given the increased prevalence of congenital heart disease and in particular pulmonary stenosis, intrauterine and postnatal follow up is warranted.

  • A, late flow velocity
  • CI, confidence interval
  • E, early flow velocity
  • TTTS, twin to twin transfusion syndrome
  • twin to twin transfusion syndrome
  • long term follow up
  • congenital heart disease
  • prenatal diagnosis
  • pulmonary stenosis

Statistics from

Twin to twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) is a severe complication of monochorionic twin pregnancies. It carries a high risk of fetal death if left untreated (80–100%) and a high perinatal morbidity and mortality.1,2 In TTTS, genetically identical twins are exposed to different haemodynamic conditions and environmental factors. Placental vascular anastomoses provide the anatomical basis for the unbalanced intertwin transfusion from donor to recipient.2–4 In the hypervolaemic recipient, cardiomegaly, biventricular hypertrophy, and tricuspid and mitral regurgitation precede the development of more severe cardiac dysfunction and may result in fetal hydrops as the end stage of intrauterine heart failure.5,6 Cardiac dysfunction progresses with increasing gestational age.7,8 In addition, various types of cardiac defects predominantly affecting the right ventricle and pulmonary artery have been reported.5,7–9 These include muscular right ventricular outflow obstruction, valvar pulmonary stenosis and atresia, and left ventricular hypertrophic non-obstructive and obstructive cardiomyopathy. In contrast, the hypovolaemic donor twin shows little cardiac pathology on fetal echocardiography but does manifest increased afterload due to raised placental resistance, as well as evidence of poor renal perfusion.

The two alternative treatments are serial amnioreduction and laser coagulation of placental vascular anastomoses.10 Amniocentesis reduces the volume and pressure of the amniotic fluid without altering the anatomical substrate. Consequently, volume overload and cardiac dysfunction continue. Interruption of intertwin vascular anastomoses by laser coagulation offers a causal treatment. The volume load is normalised in the recipient and, after a short period of acute volume overload, the donor fetus’s Doppler indices are normal.11–13 However, postnatal discordance of arterial distensibility, seen in successfully treated survivors,14 provides evidence of the altered vascular programming in the developing heart. The effect of longstanding, differing haemodynamic loading conditions on the developing heart has been examined prenatally. Postnatal follow up studies of survivors after serial amniocentesis have been restricted to the neonatal period.

To exclude progression and ensure long term resolution of haemodynamic abnormalities, we studied the outcome of all survivors from a large well defined cohort of consecutive pregnancies with severe TTTS treated by laser coagulation.


Study population

This was a prospective study of 89 survivors from 73 consecutive twin pregnancies (146 fetuses) after prenatal endoscopic laser treatment of severe TTTS. Hecher et al10 reported the survival rate and fetal outcome of this cohort. In all cases, severe TTTS was diagnosed prenatally, fulfilling the following criteria: gestational age < 25.0 weeks, single monochorionic placenta with massive polyhydramnios of the recipient, and severe oligohydramnios or anhydramnios in the donor twin.

In all pregnancies, endoscopic laser coagulation of the vascular placental anastomoses was performed at a median gestational age of 21.7 weeks (range 17.7–25.0 weeks) at the Department of Prenatal Diagnosis and Therapy, Barmbek Hospital, Hamburg, Germany. Of the 51 fetuses that died in utero or through miscarriage, only one recipient was seen to have a pulmonary stenosis on prenatal echocardiography. Patients attended their local referring hospital for further sonographic follow up and delivery. The median gestational age at delivery was 33.7 weeks (range 24.9–40.3 weeks). None of the six neonatal deaths was related to cardiac disease.

All 89 surviving infants were included in a neurodevelopmental15 and echocardiographic follow up study. The median age of the 51 recipients and 38 donors at examination was 21.5 months (range 15.5–45 months). Eighty two of the 89 surviving infants underwent detailed echocardiography. Of the remaining seven survivors, four had normal echocardiographic findings in the neonatal period and all seven patients were found to have no murmur on clinical examination. Informed consent was obtained from all parents.


Prenatally, all fetuses underwent detailed fetal echocardiography and Doppler sonography shortly before and after laser coagulation. Holosystolic tricuspid regurgitation and mitral regurgitation of more than half of the systole, hydrops (skin oedema and ascites, and pericardial or pleural effusion), and structural cardiac disease were assessed in both twins. Umbilical artery velocimetry was recorded and classified as positive, absent, or reversed end diastolic flow; and ductus venosus waveforms were classified according to positive, absent, or reversed flow during atrial contraction. Absent or reversed end diastolic flow in the umbilical artery is a sign of increased afterload due to increased placental resistance; a pathological ductus venosus waveform is an indicator for increased right ventricular end diastolic pressure. The results of the Doppler studies have previously been reported as part of a larger study.12

At the postnatal examination, parents were interviewed with regard to postnatal cardiac abnormalities and the postnatal course of both twins. The patient files were reviewed for all patients who were found to have abnormal cardiac findings or a pathological ECG or echocardiography on postnatal examination.

A 12 lead ECG was recorded (CS 100; Schiller AG, Baar, Switzerland). Blood pressure, recorded on the right arm, was obtained in a supine position.16 After the physical examination, two experienced paediatric cardiologists (WG, UH) performed complete echocardiography, including M mode, two dimensional echocardiography, continuous and pulsed wave Doppler, and colour Doppler echocardiography (Vingmed 800, 5 MHz and 3.5 MHz transducer; Vingmed, Horten, Norway). Quantitative M mode data were recorded over three cardiac cycles and the mean values of right and left ventricular end diastolic and end systolic diameter, thickness of the interventricular septum and left ventricular posterior wall, and left atrial and aortic dimension and fractional shortening of the left ventricle were obtained. The results were compared with normal values for Central European children.17 To assess the diastolic ventricular function of both the right and left ventricles, pulsed wave Doppler measurements at the mitral valve, pulmonary vein, tricuspid valve, and hepatic vein were determined18 and compared with age related normal values from the literature.19–25 Variables measured at the mitral and tricuspid valve inlets were the early (E) and late (A) flow velocities and their ratio (E:A), E wave deceleration time, the velocity–time integral of the E and A waves, the ratio of the velocity–time integrals of E and A, and the duration of the A wave. At the pulmonary vein, the variables measured were the peak flow velocities during systole and diastole, and the peak flow velocity of reversed flow during atrial contraction, as well as its duration. Sites of Doppler investigation were the orifice of the right upper pulmonary vein in the four chamber view and the mitral and tricuspid valve inflow at the leaflet tip.

Standard echocardiographic assessments of the cardiac anatomy and Doppler velocimetry were also obtained. The presence of valve regurgitation was determined by colour Doppler. Right and left ventricular outflow tract velocities, as well as the flow across the pulmonary and aortic valves, were recorded. Pulmonary valve stenosis was classified as mild (maximum pressure gradient 25–49 mm Hg), moderate (maximum pressure gradient 50–79 mm Hg), or severe (maximum pressure gradient > 80 mm Hg or equal to systemic blood pressure).

An existing atrial septal defect was classified as medium sized if the defect had a maximum diameter ⩾ 6 mm, the ratio of right ventricular to left ventricular diastolic dimensions was increased, and the ECG showed right ventricular hypertrophy; and as small if there was no sign of right ventricular hypertrophy on echocardiography and the size of the defect was between 3–6 mm. Interatrial left to right shunts with a diameter of < 3 mm were defined as persistent foramen ovale.26 Persistent foramen ovale is said to be present in more than 10% of people depending on the age of the cohort and study design27 and are considered to be a non-pathological cardiac finding.

Statistical analysis

The binominal distribution and Fisher’s exact test for the two way contingency tables were used for statistical analysis. For Fisher’s exact test, p < 0.05 was considered to indicate significance. For statistical analysis, cardiac dimensions were transformed into z scores for a given body surface area.


Congenital heart disease was not found in 78 survivors (87.6%) on physical examination, ECG, and conventional echocardiography. One child had pulmonary hypertension secondary to bronchopulmonary dysplasia. The remaining 10 infants had structural heart disease.

Structural heart disease in TTTS

In surviving twins, the prevalence of congenital heart disease (table 1) was increased (10 of 89 (11.2%), 95% confidence interval (CI) 5.5 to 19.7) in comparison with that of the normal population (0.29–0.56%).28,29

Table 1

 Prevalence of congenital heart disease in survivors after twin to twin transfusion syndrome in the study cohort compared with the prevalence at birth reported by the Baltimore-Washington infant study (WIS)28 and Wren et al29

Pulmonary stenosis was recorded only in recipients (four of 51 (7.84%), 95% CI 2.2 to 18.9) and was more common than in the general population (prevalence 0.033–0.038%). Two recipients had severe pulmonary valve stenosis, one of whom required balloon dilatation immediately postnatally and one at the age of 4 months. One recipient had a moderate valvar and another one a minimal supravalvar pulmonary stenosis.

Medium sized and small atrial septal defects were found in the same frequency in both the recipient and donor cohorts. Compared with the normal population, our study group had an increased number of medium sized atrial septal defects (2.3%, 95% CI 0.3 to 7.9; normal prevalence 0.023–0.032%).

Correlation between prenatal and postnatal cardiac findings

Overall, 28 of the 51 (55%) recipient twins had pathological findings prenatally. The most common abnormalities were cardiac chamber enlargement and hypertrophy, holosystolic tricuspid and mitral valve regurgitation, and pathological Doppler velocities of the ductus venosus as an indicator for increased right ventricular end diastolic pressure. Nine of the 38 donors exhibited absent or reversed end diastolic blood flow in the umbilical arteries. There was no significant difference in the prevalence of postnatal congenital heart disease between fetuses with and without abnormal cardiac findings before laser coagulation (table 2).

Table 2

 Prevalence of postnatal congenital heart disease and prenatal haemodynamic findings

Prenatal findings in pulmonary stenosis

Only recipients had pulmonary stenosis; therefore, prenatal findings were reviewed separately. The occurrence of pulmonary stenosis did not differ between fetuses with normal and those with abnormal cardiac findings before laser coagulation. Table 3 shows the prenatal and postnatal findings of all children with pulmonary stenosis.

Table 3

 Prenatal and postnatal course of recipients with pulmonary stenosis

Postnatal myocardial function

In children without structural heart disease, cardiac dimensions and systolic function were within the normal range at follow up (fig 1). The right ventricular diameters were normal or less than normal in both the recipient and donor without intertwin discordance.

Figure 1

 End diastolic dimensions of the left ventricle (LVDD), interventricular septum (IVSD), and right ventricle (RVDD) beyond the age of 15 months in survivors of severe twin to twin transfusion syndrome. Cardiac dimensions are transformed into z scores for a given body surface. There are no intertwin differences.

The complete evaluation of all diastolic parameters necessitated a prolonged and standardised investigation. The young children did not always tolerate this. Left and right ventricular inflow parameters were recorded in all except six survivors, but reliable Doppler velocities of the pulmonary vein were acquired for 29 of 51 (56.8%) recipients and 18 of 38 (47.3%) donors. All donors and recipients with no heart disease had normal diastolic myocardial function (data not shown). Even among recipients with severe prenatal cardiac insufficiency, systolic and diastolic variables were within the normal range.


This long term follow up study of surviving twins after prenatal laser coagulation of severe TTTS has two important results. Firstly, 87% of the survivors had a normal cardiac examination. Despite the high rate and severity of prenatal cardiac impairment in recipients, systolic or diastolic ventricular function completely normalises over the long term. This illustrates the remarkable capacity of the fetal heart for ventricular remodelling.

Secondly, the rate of pulmonary stenosis and atrial septal defects in surviving twins is increased. Pulmonary stenosis is recorded only in recipients. Possible mechanisms for this are discussed below.

Previous studies have reported varying prevalences and spectrum of heart disease in TTTS.2,7–9,30,31 Postnatal studies have focused on complications in the neonatal period. Follow up beyond the neonatal period has been done in small study cohorts7 and restricted to survivors with structural heart disease. However, more than half of the recipient twins in severe TTTS exhibit various stages of volume overload and congestive heart failure antenatally, and haemodynamic changes of the donor twins include hypovolaemia and increased afterload.

Diastolic dysfunction precedes systolic dysfunction and the study of the diastolic inflow is a more sensible parameter to determine ventricular performance.

The typical pattern of diastolic dysfunction has been described in children with cardiomyopathy resulting from increased volume or pressure load of either the right or the left ventricle.18,32,33 After relief of the pressure load, or extracardiac or intracardiac shunting, the systolic and diastolic indices in successfully treated patients improve and, over the long term, approach values found in normal subjects.33 It is important to note that these parameters are sensitive to loading conditions, heart rate, and age and can vary significantly with inspiration and expiration.18,19,21,32 Standardised investigation parameters are difficult to obtain in children below 3 years of age, resulting in highly variable results. This may be why normal values for this age group have been recorded only for small study cohorts, if at all. We were able to show that, at least beyond 15 months of age, even severe prenatal cardiac disease regresses, leaving no symptoms of systolic or diastolic dysfunction. However, we were not able to investigate the exact time point of the normalisation of ventricular function because prenatal and neonatal follow up after laser coagulation was done at the referring hospitals. Longitudinal observations of a small cohort of twins treated with intrauterine amniocentesis found that ventricular hypertrophy, contractility, and atrioventricular valve regurgitation gradually regressed and returned to normal within 40 days to six months after birth.7

Congenital heart disease

Previous studies have reported an increased prevalence of structural heart disease in TTTS. Twins are known to have more congenital malformations. However, even in monochorionic twins, in more than 90% of cases only one of the twins is affected.34 In a prospective study, Karatza et al9 compared monochorionic diamniotic pregnancies with and without TTTS (uncomplicated monochorionic diamniotic pregnancies without circulatory imbalance and haemodynamic impairment). They showed that the overall prevalence of congenital heart disease in monochorionic diamniotic twins was increased above that in singletons (6.9% in TTTS and 2.3% in uncomplicated monochorionic diamniotic twins compared with 0.56% in singletons). The increased prevalence of congenital heart disease in fetuses with TTTS was related to the significantly increased number of recipients with congenital heart disease (11.9%). This is in accordance with the prevalence of 13.7% found in our study.

The mechanism for the increased rate of congenital heart disease in monochorionic twins is unknown. The monozygotic twinning process itself may increase the incidence of congenital heart disease, with unequal postzygotic division of the inner cell mass being responsible for the discordant cardiovascular anatomy. Another explanation may be the phenotypic variability of the same genome.35 Even genetic discordances may result from variations in gene expression secondary to postzygotic mutation, parental imprinting effects, asymmetric X inactivation, and DNA methylation,36 or possibly even genetic intertwin differences caused by new mutations.

Additionally, circulatory imbalance in chronic TTTS may contribute to the development of pulmonary stenosis. Blood flow appears to be crucial to the development and growth of the cardiac chambers, valves, and arteries.14,37 Abnormal blood flow may lead to abnormal growth of cardiac and vascular structures. In recipients, a possible mechanism for this is severe and longstanding heart failure caused by chronic right ventricular volume overload, or muscular hypertrophy with severe outflow tract obstruction resulting in diminished antegrade flow with diminished growth of the right ventricular outflow tract and pulmonary artery. Additional environmental factors, such as the release of vasoactive peptides or growth factors, may contribute to the development of haemodynamic imbalance and cardiac disease.9,31,38

Effect of laser coagulation

This is the first cardiological follow up study after laser coagulation of placental anastomoses. Endoscopic laser coagulation offers a causal treatment option by interrupting the intertwin blood flow10 resulting in normalisation of the right ventricular volume load in the recipient.12,13 In contrast, amnioreduction reduces amniotic fluid volume and pressure but not the underlying cause of TTTS. After serial amniocentesis, cardiac dysfunction progresses with advancing gestational age, increasing the risk of more severe postnatal cardiac disease.5–8 Therefore, fewer fetuses treated with laser coagulation would be expected to develop structural heart disease. Despite successful laser coagulation, we found congenital heart disease and pulmonary stenosis to be as common as after serial amniocentesis.9 This suggests that, as previously discussed, factors in very early pregnancy may lead to congenital heart disease and the development of right ventricular outflow tract obstruction in the recipient.

Gardiner et al14 showed that abnormal fetal haemodynamic loading is associated with increased arterial wall stiffness in childhood in the donor after serial amniocenteses. Mid trimester laser treatment did not prevent discordant intertwin arterial wall stiffness but did alter the pattern with increased pulse wave velocity in the heavier twin. Further follow up studies—including the possible effect on long term cardiovascular performance—are needed.

Study limitations

After prenatal laser coagulation, additional follow up data on serial echocardiographic assessments were not available for all fetuses because local referring units followed up the patients. Serial measurement of pulmonary valve diameter and Doppler velocities of the outflow tract is crucial for detecting emerging pulmonary stenosis in the fetus.

Since the start of this prospective study, additional parameters obtained from tissue Doppler imaging have been developed to describe systolic and diastolic function in more detail. Therefore, further studies of this new technology may be necessary.


This study provides evidence of normalisation of cardiac function in fetuses with severe TTTS even after severe prenatal haemodynamic overload after intrauterine laser coagulation. This illustrates the remarkable adaptability of the developing heart and shows that cardiac hypertrophy and failure regress once the underlying cause has been removed. However, the increased prevalence of pulmonary stenosis in recipients justifies the need for prenatal and postnatal echocardiographic surveillance.


We thank Dr M Knapp, PhD, Institute for Medical Biometry, Informatics, and Epidemiology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany, for his support in statistical analysis of the study results.


View Abstract


  • Published Online First 6 April 2005

  • Competing interests statement: The authors have no competing interests to declare.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.