Article Text


173 A generic method to assess the adequacy of individual maternal cardiac reserve to tolerate the demands of pregnancy and labour
  1. D Barker1,
  2. N Lewis2,
  3. G Mason2,
  4. L B Tan2
  1. 1Liverpool Heart and Chest Hospital, Liverpool, UK
  2. 2Leeds General Infirmary, Leeds, UK


Introduction Clinicians often feel apprehensive when managing pregnant patients with heart disease. To complement current evaluation, we have developed a new method of directly assessing the individual patient's cardiac functional reserve through stress testing. Pregnant mothers with and without heart disease were studied to test the hypothesis that pregnant cardiac patients who possess cardiac reserve equivalent to that of controls can tolerate the usual demands of pregnancy, labour and puerperium.

Methods Fifty-one pregnant women with heart disease (mean age 30.7±6.5 (range 21–42), mean gestation 25.6±8.6 weeks) and 102 healthy pregnant women (mean age 31.4±5.0, (range 19–41), mean gestation 25.1±9.2 weeks) underwent maximal symptom-limited treadmill cardiopulmonary exercise testing. Fifty-nine non-pregnant women (mean age 32.7±5.1 (range 20–41) years) were similarly tested and used as a control group. Cardiac output (CO) was measured at peak exercise using the CO2 re-breathing method. Cardiac power output (CPO) was calculated as the product of CO and mean arterial pressure. A composite endpoint including maternal death, fetal death, emergency caesarean section for maternal distress and significant morbidities was determined.

Results All tests were performed without significant complications. Employing data from a previous study of haemodynamics during labour in healthy women, the mean CPO required during peak labour is 2.6 W. This value was adopted for investigation as the minimum required for an average woman to cope with the circulatory demands of normal labour. The healthy controls had a mean peak CPO (PkCPO) of 3.79±0.6 W and all non-pregnant women had PkCPO exceeding 2.6 W. The majority of heart disease patients were able to achieve PkCPO values overlapping their healthy counterparts. Only a small proportion of the cardiac patients had PkCPO values lower than the 2.6 W cutoff. Women were significantly more likely to have uncomplicated pregnancy, labour and puerperium if able to achieve PkCPO>2.6 W (OR 8.1, 95% CI 1.8 to 37.0, p=0.023). Pregnant women in NYHA class I had PkCPO values indistinguishable from controls (mean 3.98±0.77 W, NS); whereas symptomatic pregnant women had significantly lower values (mean 3.15±0.71W, p<0.005).

Conclusions Direct measurement of cardiac functional reserve capacity can be performed by maximal cardiopulmonary exercise testing with non-invasive assessment of PkCPO, which can be safely undertaken during pregnancy. A cutoff value of PkCPO 2.6 W was identified as the lower limit for healthy women, corresponding to that required for normal labour. Most cardiac patients studied had PkCPO values comfortably above this cutoff, and all asymptomatic (NYHA I) and low risk cardiac patients had PkCPO values similar to controls. Measurement of PkCPO allows pregnant patients to be further classified into those with adequate vs limited cardiac reserve, supplementary to existing risk stratification methods.

  • Pregnancy
  • cardiac functional reserve
  • exercise testing

Statistics from

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.