Objective Atrial fibrillation (AF) is the most common arrhythmia in women. Large studies evaluating key AF risk factors in older women are lacking. We aimed to identify risk factors for AF in postmenopausal women and measure population burden of modifiable risk factors.
Design Prospective observational study.
Setting The Women's Health Initiative (WHI) Observational Study.
Patients 93 676 postmenopausal women were followed for an average of 9.8 years for cardiovascular outcomes. After exclusion of women with prevalent AF or incomplete data, 8252 of the remaining 81 892 women developed incident AF.
Main outcome measures Incident AF was identified by WHI-ascertained hospitalisation records and diagnosis codes from Medicare claims. Multivariate Cox hazard regression analysis identified independent risk factors for incident AF.
Results Age, hypertension, obesity, diabetes, myocardial infarction and heart failure were independently associated with incident AF. Hypertension and overweight status accounted for 28.3% and 12.1%, respectively, of the population attributable risk. Hispanic and African–American participants had lower rates of incident AF (HR 0.58, 95% CI 0.47 to 0.70 and HR 0.59, 95% CI 0.53 to 0.65, respectively) than Caucasians.
Conclusions Caucasian ethnicity, traditional cardiovascular risk factors and peripheral arterial disease were independently associated with higher rates of incident AF in postmenopausal women. Hypertension and overweight status accounted for a large proportion of population attributable risk. Measuring burden of modifiable AF risk factors in older women may help target interventions.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Atrial fibrillation (AF), characterised by chaotic electrical activity in the atrium, remains the most common arrhythmia in adults, affecting over 2.2 million people in the USA,1 including up to 9.1% of women aged 85 years and older.2 AF accounts for approximately 75 000 strokes per year3 and independently increases the risk of death by 1.5–1.9-fold.4 ,5 Although AF rates are lower in women than men,2 women with AF are more likely to develop stroke3 ,6 ,7 and may be at a higher risk of death than men with AF.4 ,6
The aetiology and underlying pathophysiology of AF is poorly understood. Analyses of large prospective cohorts, including the Framingham Heart Study,8 the Cardiovascular Health Study9 and others10 ,11 have identified the principal independent risk factors of AF including hypertension, diabetes mellitus, obesity, myocardial infarction, coronary heart disease (CHD) and heart failure; these analyses were summarised in a recent systematic review.12
Large studies assessing the population-wide, independent contribution of risk factors for incident AF in older women are limited. We therefore conducted this analysis in the multiethnic Women's Health Initiative (WHI) Observational Study (OS) cohort of 93 676 postmenopausal women, one of the largest cohorts available with ascertainment of incident AF.
The WHI-OS is a prospective observational cohort study of postmenopausal women aged between 50 and 79 at baseline, who were recruited at 40 US clinical centres to assess the relationship of various self-reported demographics, such as age, ethnicity, and medical and lifestyle factors on the risk of key health outcomes, such as cardiovascular diseases, including AF, over time. Details of the study design and methods have been previously reported.13–15 Briefly, participants were recruited, primarily through mass-mailings to age-eligible women, into either a set of clinical trials or the WHI-OS. Excluded were women who were not likely to survive or remain in the vicinity of a given WHI clinic for the next 3 years or who had alcoholism, drug dependency or dementia. A total of 93 676 participants were enrolled between 1994 and 1998.
Women completed baseline self- or interviewer-administered questionnaires for eligibility screening. Baseline characteristics, including demographic, reproductive and personal and family health history, were gathered. Physical examinations, including clinic height and weight measurements, and blood collections were performed at baseline and again at 3 years. Women were sent questionnaires annually to update their medical and lifestyle information. The study was reviewed and approved by the institutional review boards at each clinical centre, and all participants provided written informed consent.
Definition of baseline variables and end points
Details of study questionnaires, physical measurements, blood collection and quality assurance have been described previously.13–15 Race and ethnicity were self-reported in the baseline questionnaire, and women who reported a race or ethnicity other than black or Hispanic, such as Asian, Native American, Pacific Islander or other race, were categorised as ‘Other’. Baseline AF was self-reported by questionnaire or documented by the presence of AF on a 12-lead ECG during the baseline clinic visit. Peripheral arterial disease (PAD) was ascertained on the baseline questionnaire by asking if the subject had ever been told by her doctor if she had ‘claudication or PAD (poor blood flow to the legs or blocked or narrowed arteries to the legs)?’. Baseline questionnaires also assessed for a history of CHD, diabetes, hyperlipidaemia, heart failure and hypertension. In addition, blood pressure measurements at the initial clinic visit identified baseline hypertension, defined as elevated systolic (≥140 mm Hg) or diastolic (≥90 mm Hg) blood pressure. Overweight status was defined as a body mass index (BMI) ≥25 kg/m2, and obese status was defined as BMI≥30 kg/m2.
Women were followed with medical history update questionnaires at years 3–8, which specifically probed for hospitalisations. Ascertainment of AF in WHI has been described previously.16 Medical records were obtained in the event of hospitalisation, and the International Classification of Disease-version 9 (ICD-9) code for AF (427.31) was extracted from these records. WHI data were linked with their Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) data using social security numbers, birth dates and death dates, with 97% of Medicare-eligible WHI participants successfully linked. Among participants with Medicare coverage, incident AF was identified by first occurrence of ICD-9 code 427.31 in any diagnosis position in the inpatient (MEDPAR), outpatient and carrier files during years 1994–2007. Because the Medicare data were available for some participants but not others at different time periods over WHI follow-up, a time-dependent indicator variable of Medicare coverage was added to the Cox hazard models described below to adjust for possible ascertainment bias related to differential exposure to CMS. Medicare time eligible for analysis included those intervals where participants were enrolled in fee-for-service Medicare and not simultaneously enrolled in a Medicare-managed care plan. Women with any single ICD-9 code of 427.31 from review of Medicare claims or hospital records were classified as having new-onset AF.
Baseline characteristics of participants with and without incident AF as well as different ethnicities were compared using either the Student t test for continuous variables or the χ2 test for categorical variables. Assessment of risk factors for incident AF was performed using multivariate Cox hazard regression analysis. For this analysis, the 4397 participants with prevalent AF and 7833 participants with incomplete data were excluded. Multivariate analyses were performed using a primary model containing covariates with known or suspected association with AF including age, race/ethnicity, hypertension, diabetes, hyperlipidaemia, heart failure, myocardial infarction, coronary artery disease, PAD, BMI, smoking, alcohol use, hormone therapy use and level of education. A secondary multivariate model was created with a combined ‘atherosclerotic burden’ variable defined as PAD, stroke, prior myocardial infarction, coronary bypass surgery or percutaneous coronary angioplasty, and adjusted for all remaining factors from the primary multivariate model.
Associations were reported as HRs with 95% CIs. The proportional hazards assumption was verified by testing the interaction of time and postmenopausal hormone therapy and through visual inspection of the log-likelihood plot of developing AF over time. Kaplan–Meier plots were drawn to depict the relationships between PAD or race/ethnicity and incident AF. The population attributable risk (PAR) of each preventable or treatable risk factor was calculated as the difference between the rate of AF in the entire cohort minus the rate of AF in those who carried the risk factor, divided by the rate of AF in the entire cohort. Analyses were performed using SAS statistical software V.9.1.
Of the 93 676 women enrolled in the OS, 4397 (4.7%) women were excluded because of self-reported baseline AF and 7833 (8.4%) were excluded for missing data, leaving 81 892 women available for analysis. Baseline characteristics of the study group, total and by self-reported race/ethnicity, are presented in table 1, as are statistics for unadjusted differences among ethnic groups. On average, participants were 63 years of age, 42.4% had a history of hypertension, 2.0% reported PAD, 3.9% were self-reported diabetic, and 0.6% had a history of heart failure. Rates of AF increase significantly with age and are higher for women with CHD in all age groups (see online supplementary figure S1). The rate of incident AF in women between 75 and 80 years of age was ∼2.8%/year in the absence of CHD, and 4.9%/year in women with CHD.
Risk factors for incident AF
Over an average of 9.8 years, 8252 participants developed new-onset AF with an average annual incidence of 1.02%, including 2021 cases identified only through WHI hospitalisation chart reviews, 4009 cases identified only through CMS coding, and 2222 identified by both methods.
Multivariate-adjusted Cox hazard regression analysis confirmed previous reports that socioeconomic factors, myocardial infarction and multiple cardiovascular risk factors, such as hypertension and diabetes, are independently associated with incident AF (table 2). Heart failure was the strongest independent predictor of incident AF, with a more than twofold higher HR. Current and past tobacco use remained independently associated with incident AF, whereas hyperlipidaemia was not associated with AF after adjustment for other risk factors. Past but not current alcohol use was associated with incident AF. We also found that PAD was predictive of incident AF with a HR of 1.53, independent of CHD, hypertension or the other major cardiovascular risk factors (table 2). Each subgroup with baseline PAD studied, including participants with hypertension and CHD, demonstrated an increased risk of developing AF (see online supplementary figure S2). A Kaplan–Meier plot comparing the cumulative hazard of AF in participants with and without PAD shows a significant separation of the curves (log-rank p<0.001) (figure 1A). In a sensitivity analysis, atherosclerotic burden, defined as presence of PAD, prior myocardial infarction, coronary bypass surgery or percutaneous coronary angioplasty, was predictive of AF with a HR of 1.63 (95% CI 1.51 to 1.75). The PAR estimates of the most significant reversible or treatable risk factors from the multivariate model are presented in table 3. The risk factor that contributed most to the population-wide risk of incident AF was hypertension (PAR=28.3%), followed by overweight or obese status (PAR=12.1%) (table 3).
Ethnicity/race and AF
After exclusion of baseline AF, the WHI-OS cohort consisted of 7234 (8.8%) African-American women, 3492 (4.3%) Hispanic women, 421 (0.45%) Asian/Pacific Islanders and 2671 (2.8%) American-Indian women (Table 1). After adjustment for age, socioeconomic status and other cardiovascular risk factors, African–American women, Hispanic women and women of other ethnicities were less likely to develop AF when compared with Caucasians (table 2). A Kaplan–Meier plot comparing the cumulative hazard of AF in participants of different ethnicities shows a significant separation of the curves (log-rank p<0.001) (figure 1B).
In this large multiethnic, postmenopausal cohort, women developed AF at an average rate of 1.02% per year, with age-matched rates that were comparable to those reported in prior studies that used Medicare data for AF ascertainment.12 ,17 Risk factors that have been established in other large cohort studies,8–12 including hypertension, CHD, diabetes and heart failure, were also associated with AF in the WHI cohort. Hypertension and obesity, important modifiable risk factors, contributed significantly to the population risk. In addition, independent of these well-established risk factors, PAD and ethnicity were associated with incident AF. Although others have reported a correlation between PAD and prevalent AF18 ,19 or subclinical atherosclerosis and incident AF, none of the previous large cohort studies8–11 evaluated the independent relationship between PAD and incident AF.
Higher BMI was significantly associated with incident AF independent of diabetes mellitus, coronary disease or other major cardiovascular risk factors, with a 17% increased risk for every 5 kg/m2. Obesity has been previously described as an important risk factor for AF,20 ,21 and the effects may be mediated through increased left atrial size20 or presence of pericardial fat.22 Studies from the Framingham8 and Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC)23 cohorts are the only other large population-based studies that have reported the burden of disease attributed to modifiable risk factors. We report that, in older women, overweight status or obesity accounted for an alarmingly high PAR (12.1%), second only to hypertension. Similarly, in the ARIC cohort, obesity accounted for 12.7% of the PAR.23 Given the obesity epidemic, this is yet another reason more attention should be paid to population-based efforts to control obesity and to further study the mechanisms linking obesity and AF.
Although the links between PAD and coronary or cerebral vascular disease are well established, it is less clear why PAD is independently associated with AF. PAD was determined by self-report at baseline and therefore may represent a subset of women with a heavier burden of atherosclerotic disease. Further studies are needed to examine the role of PAD in modulating the risk of AF itself.
We and other population studies2 ,9 ,24 have found that rates of incident AF are lower in African–Americans than Caucasians, suggesting possible underlying environmental or genetic risk factors related to race. Previous studies in veteran male populations where different race groups had similar access to healthcare reported similar findings.25 ,26 These differences persist despite adjustment for socioeconomic factors. In admixture studies of African–Americans, European ancestry is associated with AF in cohorts containing men and women.27 Further studies will be necessary to better determine how much of the difference in rates of AF is accounted for by genomic ancestry versus differential environmental exposures.
We have previously reported details of the methods used to link WHI participants to their Medicare claims records and ascertain incident AF.16 Approximately 98% of incident cases identified by WHI ECG or ICD-9 coding from hospitalisation in women enrolled in Medicare at the time were identified through CMS linkage. ICD-9 codes for identification of AF have been used by several large population-based cohorts.2 ,9 ,24 The use of ICD-9 coding to correctly identify incident AF has been validated in several large population-based cohorts,2 ,9 ,24 with a median positive predictive value of 89%,24 ,28–31 as detailed further in a recent systematic review.32 Our previous sensitivity analyses using stricter definitions of incident AF did not significantly change our findings.16 We found that HR estimates using Medicare ascertainment alone were similar to those found using WHI ascertainment (data not shown). Nevertheless, AF can be asymptomatic and paroxysmal, making the diagnosis difficult in a subgroup of women. Although there is a potential for misclassification regardless of the definition used, the biases introduced would generally be non-differential, probably resulting in dilution of associations towards the null.
In summary, we found that PAD was a significant risk factor for incident AF in postmenopausal women, independent of other cardiovascular diseases and risk factors, and that hypertension and obesity together accounted for over one-third of the PAR for AF. We also report that, compared with Caucasian women, African–American and Hispanic women are protected from developing AF, independent of socioeconomic and cardiovascular risk factors. Further studies that explore the link between vascular disease, obesity and AF are warranted.
A full listing of Women's Health Initiative investigators can be found at http://whiscience.org/publications/WHI_investigators_longlist. We thank the Women's Health Initiative investigators, staff and study participants for their outstanding dedication and commitment.
This web only file has been produced by the BMJ Publishing Group from an electronic file supplied by the author(s) and has not been edited for content.
Files in this Data Supplement:
- Data supplement 1 - Online figures
Contributors All authors were involved in study conception and design, interpretation of data, and drafting and/or editing of the article. All authors have approved the version of the manuscript to be published.
Funding This project was supported by the American Heart Association Fellow to Faculty award 11FTF7260019. The WHI program is funded by the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, National Institutes of Health, US Department of Health and Human Services through contracts HHSN268201100046C, HHSN268201100001C, HHSN268201100002C, HHSN268201100003C, HHSN268201100004C and HHSN271201100004C.
Competing interests None.
Patient consent Obtained.
Ethics approval Ethics approval was obtained from the Stanford University IRB.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.