Article Text

other Versions

Perception of symptoms is out of proportion to cardiac pathology in patients with "diastolic heart failure".
  1. Lee Ingle (l.ingle{at}
  1. Leeds Metropolitan University, United Kingdom
    1. John G F Cleland
    1. University of Hull, United Kingdom
      1. Andrew L Clark
      1. University of Hull, United Kingdom


        Background Epidemiological studies suggest that "diastolic heart failure" (DHF) is common and has a prognosis similar to that of systolic heart failure (SHF). We wanted to assess whether patients with breathlessness who were being treated for DHF had objective evidence of cardiac impairment and exercise limitation.

        Methods Consecutive patients with a clinical diagnosis of chronic heart failure completed a standardised 6-min walk test (6-MWT) and underwent an echocardiographic examination to determine the presence of major structural heart disease (MSHD). NT-proBNP was measured to determine degree of cardiac pathology.

        Results 568 patients were identified with SHF (75.7% males) and 104 with DHF (54.7% males). They were compared with 400 healthy controls (matched with DHF group for age, sex and BMI). Controls (median ± IQR; 43 (20-62 pg - mL-1)) and DHF patients (27 (13-67) pg - mL-1) had significantly lower NT-proBNP levels compared to SHF patients (178 (82-422) pg - mL-1). There was no difference in NT-proBNP levels between controls and DHF patients (P=0.348). There was no correlation between BMI and NT-proBNP in either DHF (r2=0.03; P=0.287) or SHF (r2=0.02; P=0.346) patients. Both SHF and DHF patients reported similar degrees of breathlessness. 6-MWT distance (P=0.973) was similar between SHF and DHF. DHF had a higher body mass index (P<0.0001).

        Conclusion Patients being treated for a clinical diagnosis of DHF have the same self-reported symptoms and 6-MWT performance as patients with SHF, yet have normal NT-proBNP levels. Their perception of their symptoms is out of proportion to their evidence of cardiac pathology.

        • aetiology
        • chronic heart failure
        • exercise tolerance
        • functional capacity
        • perceived symptoms

        Statistics from

        Request permissions

        If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.