Table 3

Characteristics of the subjects (initially without metabolic syndrome) after 4-year follow-up according to resting heart rate (RHR)

RHR stratification, bpm45–5455–6465–7475–8485–9495–104p Value
No. of subjects (2010)787786816 13312 91331471145
No. of subjects (2006)704705119 07612 76330961035
Mean RHR (2010), bpm51.75±2.2960.91±2.4669.90±2.4978.47±2.9189.02±2.6098.6397±2.69<0.0001
Mean RHR (2006), bpm51.73±2.1560.86±2.4669.79±2.2778.47±2.8588.93±2.5898.97±2.73<0.0001
Males (%)590 (83.81)5597 (79.38)14 635 (76.72)9959 (78.03)2467 (79.68)868 (83.86)<0.0001
Age, years52.36±12.3849.78±12.0148.18±11.7347.06±11.6546.44±12.0747.48±13.10<0.0001
Education
 Illiteracy (%)9 (1.34)41 (0.61)107 (0.58)65 (0.52)14 (0.46)8 (0.79)<0.0001
 Primary school (%)71 (10.55)475 (7.02)1094 (5.92)699 (5.58)169 (5.57)70 (6.94)
 Middle school (%)520 (77.27)5612 (82.97)15 827 (85.69)10 839 (86.50)2595 (85.50)863 (85.53)
 College/university (%)73 (10.85)636 (9.40)1443 (7.81)928 (7.41)257 (8.47)68 (6.74)
Smoking
 Never (%)392 (57.23)4147 (60.87)11 501 (62.07)7582 (60.28)1795 (58.85)593 (58.42)<0.0001
 Former (%)52 (7.59)362 (5.31)849 (4.58)515 (4.09)136 (4.46)57 (5.62)
 Current (%)241 (35.18)2304 (33.82)6180 (33.35)4481 (35.63)1119 (36.69)365 (35.96)
Alcohol drinking
 Never (%)359 (52.49)3785 (55.51)11 084 (59.80)7483 (59.48)1762 (57.81)604 (59.51)<0.0001
 Former (%)25 (3.65)186 (2.73)514 (2.77)317 (2.52)79 (2.59)32 (3.15)
 Current (%)300 (43.86)2847 (41.76)6936 (37.42)4780 (38.00)1207 (39.60)379 (37.34)
Physical activities
 Inactive (%)42 (6.24)571 (8.47)1594 (8.66)1240 (9.91)316 (10.43)108 (10.71)<0.0001
 Moderately active (%)494 (73.40)5177 (76.75)14 317 (77.76)9873 (78.93)2430 (80.17)786 (77.98)
 Very active (%)137 (20.36)997 (14.78)2501 (13.58)1395 (11.15)285 (9.40)114 (11.31)
Hypertension (%)171 (24.29)1743 (24.72)5622 (29.47)4179 (32.74)1122 (36.24)450 (43.48)<0.0001
Dyslipidaemia (%)140 (19.89)1520 (21.56)4461 (23.39)3214 (25.18)778 (25.13)275 (26.57)<0.0001
Diabetes mellitus (%)14 (1.99)196 (2.78)575 (3.01)502 (3.93)160 (5.17)74 (7.15)<0.0001
BMI, kg/m224.12±3.2324.22±3.1524.46±3.1924.39±3.2324.29±3.3223.92±3.41<0.0001
SBP, mm Hg122.06±19.75122.21±18.18124.25±18.33126.21±18.78128.36±19.84131.53±20.67<0.0001
DBP, mm Hg77.44±9.7478.73±10.1780.50±10.4581.89±11.2782.85±11.5084.31±11.78<0.0001
TG, mmol/L1.23±0.881.28±0.911.37±1.011.40±1.111.44±1.081.51±1.13<0.0001
HDL, mmol/L1.61±0.381.59±0.381.59±0.391.56±0.371.59±0.381.64±0.40<0.0001
LDL, mmol/L2.08±0.852.19±0.862.29±0.902.34±0.852.32±0.842.32±0.91<0.0001
TC, mmol/L4.69±1.144.82±1.024.84±1.094.92±1.054.96±1.074.96±1.13<0.0001
FBG, mmol/L4.93±1.075.01±0.995.05±1.045.20±1.215.34±1.385.51±1.84<0.0001
CRP, mg/L0.57 (0.20–1.70)0.62 (0.23–1.90)0.69 (0.24–1.94)0.62 (0.22–1.69)0.72 (0.28–1.94)0.81 (0.28–2.20)<0.0001
UA, mmol/L290.35±80.16281.56±79.25276.66±77.10275.50±78.35277.23±80.17277.34±78.65<0.0001
CR, µmol/L88.93±21.6389.52±25.6292.04±27.1989.14±25.7689.06±30.7190.22±31.97<0.0001
WC, cm84.71±9.2384.63±9.6284.44±9.2884.30±9.3184.14±9.9583.33±9.56<0.0001
Stroke (%)15 (2.13)123 (1.74)239 (1.25)182 (1.43)41 (1.32)16 (1.55)0.0344
Myocardial infarction (%)8 (1.14)65 (0.92)145 (0.76)124 (0.97)25 (0.81)11 (1.06)0.3469
All-cause mortality (%)1 (0.14)16 (0.23)29 (0.15)15 (0.12)3 (0.10)2 (0.19)0.4969
β-Blocker use (%)1 (0.14)11 (0.16)25 (0.13)9 (0.07)3 (0.10)3 (0.29)0.2804
  • See table 1 for CRP value explanation.

  • BMI, body mass index; CR, creatine; CRP, C reactive protein; DBP, diastolic blood pressure; FBG, fasting blood glucose; HDL, high density lipoprotein-cholesterol; LDL, low density lipoprotein-cholesterol; SBP, systolic blood pressure; TC, total cholesterol; TG, triglycerides; UA, uric acid; WC, waist circumference.