An economic analysis of an aggressive diagnostic strategy with single photon emission computed tomography myocardial perfusion imaging and early exercise stress testing in emergency department patients who present with chest pain but nondiagnostic electrocardiograms: Results from a randomized trial☆,☆☆,★,★★
Introduction
Each year 5 million patients with chest pain are seen in US emergency departments.1 Although the immediate objective for emergency physicians is to identify patients with ST-segment elevation as candidates for initiation of reperfusion therapy for acute myocardial infarction (AMI),2, 3 the great majority of chest pain patients do not have ST-segment elevation or new ST-segment depression4 and pose a diagnostic dilemma.5 Typically, 60% of chest pain patients presenting to the ED are admitted for further cardiac evaluation, although fewer than 15% are proved to have AMIs.6 In addition, initial evaluations in the ED inadvertently miss 4% to 5% of patients with AMI.7, 8
Although the medical history, physical examination, and ECG provide considerable information for short-term risk assessment,9 emergency physicians require additional diagnostic tests for patients who are not initially classified as high risk.5 Several tests including radionuclide myocardial perfusion (single photon emission computed tomography [SPECT]) imaging,10, 11 echocardiography,12 exercise stress testing,13, 14 and assays of creatine kinase MB (CK-MB) isoenzyme and its subforms,15 myoglobin,16 troponin I,17 and troponin T18 are currently used for this purpose.19, 20 SPECT imaging has advantages over several of these technologies because it assesses the functional significance of coronary artery disease, which may not be predicted by coronary anatomy alone,21 has a high sensitivity and specificity for AMI,10, 11, 22 is not time-dependent,23 and has a demonstrated effectiveness in distinguishing patients at high and low risk for cardiac events during the acute phase24 and through 90 days of follow-up.25 Additionally, patients with normal SPECT imaging results and a normal or nondiagnostic exercise ECG have favorable 1-year outcomes.26
Although there is evidence that SPECT imaging in the ED can substantially reduce the number of unnecessary admissions11 and lead to potential cost savings in patients with typical chest pain and nondiagnostic ECGs,11, 27 these earlier results need to be validated with a prospective, randomized clinical trial. The hypothesis of the present study was that the routine use of rest SPECT imaging and early exercise stress testing to assess intermediate-risk patients with chest pain and no ECG evidence of acute ischemia would lead to earlier discharges, more discriminate use of coronary angiography, and an overall reduction in average costs of care with no adverse clinical outcomes. We also hypothesized that these reductions would occur in non-AMI patients and that care for AMI patients would not be negatively affected.
Our study was designed as a cost-minimization analysis and assumed no difference in clinical effectiveness between the 2 diagnostic strategies.28 We also assumed that a rest SPECT imaging diagnostic strategy would only be a viable option for hospitals with high-volume EDs. Thus, the analysis was performed from the hospital’s perspective.
Section snippets
Materials and methods
Patients presenting to the ED of 2 study sites between July 1, 1996, and September 30, 1997, with chest pain believed to be of cardiac origin were evaluated for eligibility to participate. One site was a tertiary care institution in the suburbs of Jacksonville, FL; the other site was an urban hospital with a high percentage of managed care patients. Inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) ongoing chest pain with a duration of less than 12 hours; (2) no ECG ST-segment elevation or depression
Results
A total of 46 patients were enrolled in the study (6% of the 757 unspecified chest pain patients seen at the 2 sites during the enrollment period). Twenty-three patients were randomly assigned to each of the 2 diagnostic arms (conventional and perfusion imaging–guided). For a relatively small sample size, the 2 cohorts were remarkably similar. Mean patient age was similar (58 and 63 years in the conventional and perfusion imaging–guided arms, respectively). Most patients were white, and women
Discussion
The majority of patients who present to EDs with chest pain have normal or nondiagnostic ECG findings. Only about 15% to 17% have an acute coronary syndrome in which salvage of myocardium is time dependent,33, 34, 35 whereas the great majority of these patients have a good prognosis and can be considered for outpatient management. Thus, early risk stratification of patients with chest pain and a nondiagnostic ECG has the potential to improve cost efficacy in those without disease and
Acknowledgements
We thank Linda Davidson-Ray, BA, for management of the cost collection activities; Marian Jones-Richmond, BBA, for construction of the database; Rita Kaurs, MSHSA, and Edward Bernbom, DPM, for their technical assistance and expertise; Kevin J. Anstrom, MS, for his assistance with the statistical analyses, and Kathy B. Gates, BS, for coordination of the core laboratories.
References (41)
- et al.
A rapid diagnostic and treatment center for patients with chest pain in the emergency department
Ann Emerg Med
(1995) - et al.
Evaluation of chest pain in the emergency department
Curr Prob Cardiol
(1997) - et al.
Value of acute rest sestamibi perfusion imaging for evaluation of patients admitted to the emergency department with chest pain
J Am Coll Cardiol
(1997) - et al.
Clinical value of acute rest technetium-99m tetrofosmin tomographic myocardial perfusion imaging in patients with acute chest pain and nondiagnostic electrocardiograms
J Am Coll Cardiol
(1998) - et al.
An evaluation of technologies for identifying acute cardiac ischemia in the emergency department: executive summary of a National Heart Attack Alert Program Working Group Report
Ann Emerg Med
(1997) - et al.
A national survey of emergency department chest pain centers in the United States
Am J Cardiol
(1998) - et al.
Myocardial risk area defined by technetium-99m sestamibi imaging during percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty: comparison with coronary angiography
J Am Coll Cardiol
(1993) - et al.
Comprehensive strategy for the evaluation and triage of the chest pain patient
Ann Emerg Med
(1997) - et al.
Technetium-99m sestamibi myocardial perfusion imaging in the emergency room evaluation of chest pain
J Am Coll Cardiol
(1994) - et al.
Ninety day follow-up of patients in the emergency department with chest pain who undergo initial single-photon emission computed tomographic perfusion scintigraphy with technetium 99m-labeled sestamibi
J Nucl Cardiol
(1996)
One-year prognosis of patients with normal planar or single-photon emission compute tomographic technetium 99-m labeled sestamibi exercise imaging
J Nucl Cardiol
Potential cost effectiveness of initial myocardial perfusion imaging for assessment of emergency department patients with chest pain
Am J Cardiol
Prognostic factors in angina pectories—a prospective study
J Chron Dis
Incremental value of prognostic testing in patients with known or suspected ischemic heart disease: a basis for optimal utilization of exercise technetium-99m sestamibi myocardial perfusion single-photon emission computed tomography
J Am Coll Cardiol
Outcome in suspected acute myocardial infarction with normal or minimally abnormal admission electrocardiographic findings
Am J Cardiol
Failure of new biochemical markers to exclude acute myocardial infarction at admission
Lancet
Utility and safety of immediate exercise testing of low-risk patients admitted to the hospital for suspected acute myocardial infarction
Am J Cardiol
Evaluation of chest pain in low-risk patients presenting to the emergency department: the role of immediate exercise testing
Ann Emerg Med
Routine stress testing for triage of patients with chest pain: is it worth the candle?
Ann Emerg Med
National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 1995 Emergency Department Survey. Advance Data From Vital Health Statistics
Cited by (94)
Dr. Galen Wagner (1939-2016) as an Academic Writer: An Overview of his Peer-reviewed Scientific Publications
2017, Journal of Electrocardiology2015 ACR/ACC/AHA/AATS/ACEP/ASNC/NASCI/SAEM/SCCT/SCMR/SCPC/SNMMI/STR/STS Appropriate Utilization of Cardiovascular Imaging in Emergency Department Patients With Chest Pain: A Joint Document of the American College of Radiology Appropriateness Criteria Committee and the American College of Cardiology Appropriate Use Criteria Task Force
2016, Journal of the American College of Cardiology2015 ACR/ACC/AHA/AATS/ACEP/ASNC/NASCI/SAEM/SCCT/SCMR/SCPC/SNMMI/STR/STS Appropriate Utilization of Cardiovascular Imaging in Emergency Department Patients with Chest Pain :A Joint Document of the American College of Radiology Appropriateness Criteria Committee and the American College of Cardiology Appropriate Use Criteria Task Force
2016, Journal of the American College of RadiologyImaging techniques for the assessment of suspected acute coronary syndromes in the emergency department
2014, Current Problems in CardiologyRest myocardial perfusion imaging: A valuable tool in ED
2013, American Journal of Emergency MedicineCitation Excerpt :Rest myocardial perfusion imaging, in this context, can be helpful. From previous studies, this procedure is cost-effective, avoiding unnecessary admissions and a long permanence in the hospital [26-29]. Considering unstable angina, ideally, the isotope injection should be done during ongoing chest pain or within 2 hours after chest pain relief [9].
- ☆
Supported in part by grants from Medi-Physics, Inc, Amersham Healthcare, Arlington Heights, IL.
- ☆☆
Address for reprints: Eric L. Eisenstein, DBA, Duke University Medical Center Box 3865, Durham, NC 27710; 919-668-8984,fax 919-668-7057; E-mail [email protected].
- ★
0196-0644/2000/$12.00 + 0
- ★★
47/1/103482