Article Text

Download PDFPDF

11 The impact of misclassifying left ventricular size if indexing to body surface area is not performed
  1. Carl Hayward1,
  2. Carlos Perez1,
  3. Hitesh Patel2,
  4. Kyriacos Mouyis1,
  5. Ketna Patel3,
  6. Mohammed Akhtar1,
  7. Daniel Harding1,
  8. Gamith Adasuriya1,
  9. Holly Gillott1,
  10. George Harvey1,
  11. Imelda Sotto1,
  12. Sanjeev Bhattacharyya1
  1. 1Barts Health NHS Trust
  2. 2Imperial College
  3. 3West Middlesex Hospital

Abstract

Introduction Guidelines recommend indexing measurements of left ventricle (LV) size to body surface area (BSA) to improve clinical validity. We sought to highlight the potential impact of misclassifying LV size in patients if indexing is not performed.

Methods We reviewed the reports of all trans-thoracic echocardiograms performed at a large tertiary centre for cardiology and compared proportions of patients with LV dilatation based on LV internal diastolic dimension (LVIDd) > 5.8 cm (male), >5.2 cm (female) or indexed (Dubois) LVIDd > 3.0cm/m2 (male), > 3.1cm/m2 (female). We also identified all reports with a diagnosis of moderate-severe or severe aortic regurgitation and compared proportions of patients with LV dilatation that would reach the threshold for surgical intervention when indexed and non-indexed values are used.

Results 20397 echocardiogram reports were reviewed. LV dilatation was present in 2821 (13.8%) based on non-indexed LVIDd compared to 2083 (10.2%) using indexed LVDD. After indexing for BSA 2202 (10.8%) patients changed category: 1470 (7.2%) patients deemed to have a dilated LV based on LVIDd were reclassified as normal, whereas 732 (3.6%) patients deemed to have a normal sized LV were reclassified as dilated when LVIDd was indexed.

Reports of 71 patients with moderate-severe or severe aortic regurgitation were reviewed. 5 (7.0%) had a LV internal systolic dimension (LVIDs) >5cm meeting criteria to consider surgery. When indexed to BSA, 15 (21.1%) had indexed LVIDs >2.5cm/m2 with 11 (15.5%) changing from normal LVIDs to dilated LVIDs when indexed.

Conclusion Indexing left ventricular dimensions results in reclassification of 10.8% of patients, which could have implications on clinical management decisions. Furthermore, up to 15.5% of patients with aortic regurgitation may transition from non-dilated to dilated LVIDs when indexed values are used and so impact on timing of surgical referral. Uncorrected and BSA corrected quantitative measurements should be available on all echocardiogram reports.

Conflict of Interest None

  • LV dilatation
  • Indexing to body surface area
  • Aortic regurgitation

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.