Background The results of immediate and short term follow up of balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve have been well documented, but there is limited information on long term follow up.
Objective To evaluate the results of three to 10 year follow up of balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve in children and adolescents.
Setting Tertiary care centre/university hospital.
Design Retrospective study.
Methods and results 85 patients (aged between 1 day and 20 years, mean (SD) 7.0 (6.4) years) underwent balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve during an 11 year period ending August 1994. There was a resultant reduction in the peak to peak gradient from 87 (38) to 26 (22) mm Hg. Immediate surgical intervention was not required. Residual gradients of 29 (17) mm Hg were measured by catheterisation (n = 47) and echo Doppler (n = 82) at intermediate term follow up (two years). When individual results were scrutinised, nine of 82 patients had restenosis, defined as a peak gradient of 50 mm Hg or more. Seven of these patients underwent repeat balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve: peak gradients were reduced from 89 (40) to 38 (20) mm Hg. Clinical evaluation and echo Doppler data of 80 patients showed that residual peak instantaneous Doppler gradients were 17 (15) mm Hg at long term follow up (three to 10 years, median seven), with evidence for late restenosis in one patient (1.3%). Surgical intervention was necessary to relieve fixed infundibular stenosis in three patients and supravalvar pulmonary stenosis in one. Repeat balloon dilatation was performed to relieve restenosis in two patients. Actuarial reintervention free rates at one, two, five, and 10 years were 94%, 89%, 88%, and 84%, respectively. Pulmonary valve regurgitation was noted in 70 of 80 patients at late follow up, but neither right ventricular dilatation nor paradoxical interventricular septal motion developed.
Conclusions The results of late follow up of balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve are excellent. Repeat balloon dilatation was performed in 11% of patients and surgical intervention for subvalvlar or supravalvar stenosis in 5%. Most patients had mild residual pulmonary regurgitation but right ventricular volume overload did not develop and surgical intervention was not required. Balloon dilatation is the treatment of choice in the management of moderate to severe stenosis of the pulmonary valve. Further follow up studies should be undertaken to evaluate the significance of residual pulmonary regurgitation.
- balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve
- pulmonary stenosis
- pulmonary regurgitation
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Since the first description of balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve by Kan et al,1 her group2 and others have used this technique for the relief of stenosis of the pulmonary valve in neonates, infants, and children. Immediate and short term results have been well documented (an extensive reference list of publications reporting the results of immediate and intermediate term follow up is available from the corresponding author). However, there are limited data on long term follow up (more than five years). The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of long term follow up of balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve in children and adolescents. We also examined the development of restenosis and pulmonary valve regurgitation during late follow up and reintervention free rates following balloon dilatation.
Patients and methods
The series comprised 85 consecutive children and adolescents (aged between 1 day and 20 years) who underwent balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve during an 11 year period ending August 1994. Fifty eight procedures were performed at the King Faisal Specialist Hospital and Research Center, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia and 27 at the University of Wisconsin Children’s Hospital, Madison, Wisconsin, USA. Immediate and short term results of the first 56 children have been reported,3 ,4 but the results of long term follow up have not been published.
INCLUSION AND EXCLUSION CRITERIA
Patients who fulfilled the following criteria were selected for balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve: a peak to peak systolic pressure gradient across the pulmonary valve of 50 mm Hg or greater with a normal cardiac index irrespective of symptoms.5Patients who underwent balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve for palliation of cyanosis and pulmonary oligaemia secondary to stenosis of the pulmonary valve associated with a large interventricular communication6 ,7 were excluded. However, patients with an associated atrial septal defect or patient foramen ovale with right to left atrial shunt7 were included.
Informed consent was obtained from the parents of each patient. Children old enough to understand were asked for their consent. The technique of balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve that was used has been described in detail,8 ,9 and is similar to that performed by others.2 ,10 The size of the balloon was within 1–2 mm of the size of the pulmonary valve annulus in the initial part of the study. Subsequent to reports of the usefulness of larger balloons11-13 an attempt was made to achieve a balloon/annulus ratio between 1.2 and 1.4. A double balloon technique11 ,14 ,15 was used in 12 patients (14%).
Follow up included clinical evaluation and echo Doppler studies at day 1 and 3, six, and 12 months after balloon dilatation and yearly thereafter. Clinical evaluation focused on symptoms and the need for reintervention. Echo Doppler assessed the maximum peak instantaneous gradient across the pulmonary valve16 ,17 and pulmonary regurgitation. The results of pulmonary regurgitation were semiquantitated by modification of the criteria described by Cooperet al (table 1).18 The size of the right and left ventricles were also measured and M mode echocardiograms were evaluated for abnormalities of interventricular septal motion. Forty seven patients (55%) underwent cardiac catheterisation at a mean (SD) of 9 (4) months after balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve. Catheterisation was performed in most patients in the first half of the study, whereas this procedure was carried out in only selected patients thereafter.
Data are expressed as means (SD) for continuous, normally distributed variables. Medians (range) are given when the data are not normally distributed. Values before and after balloon dilatation were compared by two tailed or paired t tests, or an appropriate non-parametric analogue. Independent sample ttests were used for between group comparisons of normally distributed variables. Fisher’s exact, Kruskal-Wallis, McNemars, or Mann-Whitney tests were used, as appropriate, for between group comparisons of categorical, ordinal, or not normally distributed variables. Multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed to identify predictors of restenosis of the pulmonary valve. Actuarial analysis of event free rates were calculated by the Kaplan-Meir method. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05 and adjusted using Bonferroni’s technique when multiple comparisons were made.
Eighty five patients (43 male) with a weight range of 2.9–75 kg (mean (SD) 21 (16) kg) underwent balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve. The mean (SD) age was 7.0 (6.4) years; seven were neonates, 15 were between 1 and 12 months, 35 were between 1 and 10 years old, and the remaining 28 were between 11 and 20 years old. There were no associated cardiac defects in 39 patients (46%); a patent foramen ovale was present in 38 (45%). In the remaining eight children tiny patent ductus arteriosus were present in two, persistent left superior vena cava in two, moderate to severe tricuspid regurgitation in two, Ebstein’s anomaly of the tricuspid valve in one, and stenosis of the right pulmonary artery in one. Three children (3.5%) had previously undergone surgical valvotomy of the pulmonary valve approximately one year before balloon dilatation. One child (1.2%) had Noonan’s syndrome.
IMMEDIATE AND INTERMEDIATE TERM FOLLOW UP
The peak to peak systolic pressure gradient was reduced by catheter pullback across the pulmonary valve (fig 1) immediately following balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve and at intermediate follow up (defined as two years or less) (fig 1). The maximum peak instantaneous Doppler gradient also declined immediately following balloon dilatation and at intermediate term follow up (fig 2). These findings are similar to those reported previously.3 ,4 ,8 ,9 When the results of individual patients were scrutinised, nine (11%) of 82 patients had restenosis defined as a gradient of 50 mm Hg or more at intermediate term follow up. Seven of these patients underwent repeat balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve at a mean interval of 12 months after initial balloon dilatation: peak to peak gradients were reduced from 89 (40) to 38 (20) mm Hg (p < 0.01). Predictors of restenosis were identified by multivariate stepwise logistic regression analysis as described previously19: a balloon/annulus ratio of less than 1.2 and a pulmonary valve gradient of 30 mm Hg immediately following dilatation, as observed in our initial study.19 The prevalence, management, and resolution of infundibular obstruction were similar to those described in our previous report20 except for the requirement for surgery: two additional children required reintervention during intermediate term follow up: both had surgical resection of severe, fixed infundibular pulmonary obstruction at two months and two years, respectively, after dilatation.
LATE FOLLOW UP
Three to 10 year follow up (median seven years) was available in 80 patients. Five patients were lost to follow up: there was no evidence of obstruction at the last available follow up. None of the 80 patients had symptoms referable to the cardiovascular system.
The maximum peak instantaneous gradient at long term follow up evaluation was 17 (15) mm Hg, significantly lower (p < 0.01) than the gradients seen before balloon dilatation and at intermediate term follow up (fig 2).
Four children (5%) who had no reintervention during intermediate term follow up required reintervention during late follow up. One child underwent surgery for severe supravalvar pulmonary stenosis and secundum atrial septal defect 36 months after balloon dilatation. Another child had severe, fixed infundibular obstruction 102 months after balloon dilatation. The third child underwent repeat balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve 93 months after initial balloon dilatation. This child had a gradient of 52 mm Hg during intermediate term follow up, but did not undergo repeat intervention. The fourth child developed late restenosis with a gradient of 71 mm Hg, requiring repeat balloon dilatation 66 months after initial balloon dilatation. Actuarial event free rates (fig 3) suggest that 94%, 89%, 88%, and 84% of patients are free from reintervention at one, two, five, and 10 year follow up.
The right ventricular end diastolic dimension (mean (SD) 17.2 (5.4) mm) was similar (p > 0.1) to dimensions before balloon dilatation and at intermediate term follow up (fig 4). None of the patients had an enlarged right ventricle compared with normal values for the square root of body surface area.21 The left ventricular end diastolic dimension (mean (SD) 37.0 (7.8) mm) was increased (p < 0.01) compared with the dimension before dilatation (29.3 (8.6) mm), reflecting growth in ventricular size with increasing patient age. The values are within the normal range when normalised to the square root of body surface area.21
The incidence of pulmonary regurgitation by Doppler was higher (p < 0.001) at late follow up (fig 5A); there was gradual increase in the number of patients with pulmonary regurgitation. In addition, there was an increase in the number of patients with flat interventricular septal motion (fig 5B). However, none had paradoxical septal motion. On the basis of a lack of right ventricular dilatation and the absence of paradoxical septal motion, none of the patients was considered to have significant pulmonary regurgitation. Surgical intervention for treatment of pulmonary regurgitation was not required.
FOLLOW UP STUDIES
This study reports the results of long term follow up (three to 10 years) in 80 patients who underwent balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve before August 1994. There is evidence for minimal restenosis beyond what was observed at intermediate term follow up (11%) and residual gradients are low at 17 (15) mm Hg. Actuarial reintervention free rates were 88% at five years and 84% at 10 years after balloon dilatation. The incidence of pulmonary regurgitation increased but the condition was not severe and surgical intervention was not required.
Immediate and intermediate term results of balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve for relief of congenital stenosis of the pulmonary valve have been reported by several workers (referenced extensively elsewhere).9 ,22 The results of long term follow up have not been reported; results of the longest follow up periods were 4.9 and 5.3 years.23 ,24 McCrindle and Kan23reported the results of a 4.9 year (mean) follow up of 46 patients. They found a residual peak instantaneous Doppler gradient of 20 (13) mm Hg. The incidence of mild pulmonary regurgitation was 80%. O’Connor et al reported the results of a 5.3 year (mean) follow up of 20 patients.24 They found a residual follow up Doppler gradient of 24 (3) mm Hg. The incidence of mild pulmonary regurgitation was 45%. These results as well as our own data, reported herein, suggest that residual gradients remain low at late follow up, but with a higher incidence of pulmonary regurgitation.
COMPARISON WITH SURGERY
Comparison of follow up results of surgical valvotomy versus balloon dilatation is problematic in that: (1) the number of available patients who undergo balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve at follow up is small; (2) the duration of available follow up after balloon dilatation is relatively short; and (3) there are problems inherent in comparing “older” historical surgical results with those of “current” balloon dilatation. In a previous review9 in which we compared the results derived from nine representative surgical reports with those from 11 reports of treatment with balloon dilatation mortality and morbidity seemed to be greater after surgery; however, the recurrence rate was higher following balloon dilatation.
O’Conner et al who compared the results of balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve (n = 20) with those of an age and gradient matched surgical control group found slightly higher Doppler peak instantaneous gradients in the balloon group (24 (2.7) mm Hg) than in the surgical controls (16 (1.5) mm Hg).24 The incidence of mild pulmonary regurgitation was 45% in the balloon group, while the incidences of mild and moderate pulmonary regurgitation were 45% and 45%, respectively, in the surgical controls. Follow up duration was significantly shorter (5.3 (0.3)v 11.7 (0.5) years) in the balloon group than in the surgical controls, thus making it difficult to interpret the data, a problem similar to that described in the aforementioned review.9
The advantages of balloon dilatation in terms of morbidity and mortality9 are clear. The degree of pulmonary regurgitation also seems to be better following balloon dilatation than after surgery.24 The recurrence rate seems to be higher9 with balloon dilatation than with surgical treatment. Initially, most workers used small balloons (balloon/annulus ratio approximately 1.0); however, after data on larger balloons became available11-13 many workers started using large balloons to achieve a balloon/annulus ratio between 1.2 and 1.4. Indeed, recurrences were not found when we examined the results of patients who underwent balloon dilatation with a balloon larger than 1.2 times the valve annulus.13 It is likely that balloon treatment is better than surgery, especially when the balloon/annulus ratio is between 1.2 and 1.4.
Balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve produces excellent immediate gradient relief in children and adolescents with stenosis of the pulmonary valve. While gradient relief is maintained for the group as a whole at intermediate term follow up, restenosis (11%) was found when the results of individual patients were reviewed. Repeat balloon dilatation gave excellent relief of obstruction. At late follow up (three to 10 years), there is evidence for additional minimal restenosis, but the incidence of pulmonary regurgitation is increased. Right ventricular volume overload did not develop and surgical intervention was not required. Actuarial event free rates were 88% at five years and 84% at 10 years. On the basis of these data, we conclude that balloon dilatation of the pulmonary valve is the treatment of choice in the management of isolated stenosis of the pulmonary valve. Careful longer term follow up (10–20 years) to evaluate the significance of pulmonary regurgitation should be continued.
The authors thank Drs M E Fawzy, F Kutayli, J M Levy, M K Mardini, L Solymar, and M K Thapar for their contributions to the clinical material. We also thank Mr J Hormann and Ms K Thompson for assistance with the statistical analysis and preparation of the manuscript.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.