The physiological mechanisms that link myocyte depolarisation and contraction are referred to collectively as excitation–contraction coupling. This important process uses calcium as a second messenger to convert electrical depolarisation of the myocyte sarcolemma into the coordinated contraction of the cell’s internal myofilament apparatus. The inotropic properties of the cell are determined by the efficiency of this process and when this efficiency is lost contractile dysfunction and heart failure develop, along with a propensity for arrhythmias. Previous attempts to use positive inotropic drugs in the management of chronic heart failure have been disappointing. Such drugs have been associated with unacceptable side effects and worse morbidity and mortality outcomes, primarily through their non-specific amplification of intracellular cascade pathways that modify the cell’s inotropic state. As a result of recent advances in our understanding of how excitation–contraction coupling works in both health and disease it may be possible to design more specifically targeted drug treatment that has the potential to avoid the detrimental effect of currently available drugs while at the same time improving the inotropic properties of the cell.
- calcium channel
- sarcoplasmic reticulum
- cardiac arrhythmia
- heart failure
- E-C, excitation-contraction
- NCX, sarcolemmal Na+/Ca2+ exchanger
- RyR2, cardiac ryanodine receptor
- SERCA, sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+/ATPase pump
- SR, sarcoplasmic reticulum
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
- E-C, excitation-contraction
- NCX, sarcolemmal Na+/Ca2+ exchanger
- RyR2, cardiac ryanodine receptor
- SERCA, sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+/ATPase pump
- SR, sarcoplasmic reticulum
Cardiac excitation–contraction (E-C) coupling refers to the process whereby myocyte excitation (in the form of membrane depolarisation) is used as the stimulus for a coordinated movement of calcium around the cell to bring about contraction.1 It is a highly evolved and efficient amplification system, which uses both intracellular and sarcolemmal bound components. Great advances have been made over recent years in our understanding of how these components work together and are regulated under normal physiological conditions. Cardiac E-C coupling plays a vital role in maintaining the normal inotropic and electrical properties of the heart and it is not surprising that when this process is defective both heart failure and cardiac arrhythmias can result. Previous inotropic treatments that non-specifically amplified cardiac E-C coupling gain have largely been discredited as effective treatments in chronic heart failure.2 The design of therapeutic strategies that use our increased understanding of this process to target specific defects within it represents a new opportunity in drug development that will avoid many of the limitations seen with currently available drugs.
E-C COUPLING IN THE NORMAL HEART
The key cellular components of cardiac E-C coupling and calcium movement around the myocyte are outlined in fig 1. When the myocyte depolarises, extracellular Ca2+ enters the cell through the L type voltage dependent (dihydropyridine sensitive) calcium channel, a phenomenon represented by the phase 2 plateau of the cardiac action potential.3 This inward Ca2+ current is, on its own, insufficient to bring about the required conformational change in troponin needed for contraction to occur. Additional calcium is required and this is obtained from a pool of stored calcium within the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) of the cell. The initial inward movement of Ca2+ acts as an amplification signal for the release of this storage pool of SR calcium. This process, known as “calcium induced calcium release”,4 occurs through an SR membrane ion channel known as the cardiac ryanodine receptor (RyR2).5 Individual populations of RyR2 localise in areas of the SR membrane, adjacent to L type voltage dependent channels within the T tubules of the sarcolemma.6 Influx of calcium through this latter channel activates its associated local population of RyR2 channels, causing a synchronised release of calcium known as a Ca2+ spark.7 The synchronised release of multiple Ca2+ sparks throughout the cell following depolarisation creates a global intracellular Ca2+ transient of sufficient magnitude to bring about contraction (fig 2). Conversely, myocyte relaxation results from closure of RyR2 and the rapid removal of cytosolic calcium, either by reuptake into the SR through the sarcoplasmic Ca2+/ATPase pump (SERCA), or by its efflux out of the cell through the sarcolemmal Na+/Ca2+ exchanger (NCX). These two processes balance the earlier cellular influx and SR release of calcium so that there is no net gain or loss of cellular calcium with each contraction–relaxation cycle.
The above channels and pumps interact with a variety of structural and regulatory proteins, the nature and function of which are gradually emerging. Of particular importance among these are the various enzymes that mediate phosphorylation of both the channels and the pumps themselves, and other regulatory elements attached to them. Such phosphorylation is the final event in a signal amplification cascade that begins with β1 adrenergic receptor activation, either by sympathetic nerves or by circulating catecholamines. This subsequently allows the activation of adenylate cyclase and the generation of cyclic AMP, which in turn switches on phosphorylating enzymes such as protein kinase A. In this way the activity of cardiac E-C coupling can be modified by adrenergic input and this process underlies the improvements in haemodynamic variables seen with many positive inotropic drugs and the fight and flight response of the heart. Important functional consequences of phosphorylation include a greater influx of calcium through the L type voltage dependent channel for any given depolarisation and a greater release of SR calcium through RyR2.1 These directly inotropic enhancing consequences are balanced by the lusitropic effects of greater SR calcium reuptake through SERCA (as a result of phosphorylation of its regulatory protein phospholamban) and the dissociation of calcium from troponin, which occurs when this myofilament protein is phosphorylated. Although these lusitropic actions enhance myocyte relaxation they are nevertheless key to ensuring sufficient SR calcium is available for the next wave of depolarisation and thus also contribute to the overall gain in cardiac E-C coupling that adrenergic stimulation mediates.
CARDIAC EXCITATION–CONTRACTION COUPLING IN THE FAILING HEART
At the cellular level various factors may contribute towards defective contractile function in heart failure, including apoptosis, energy starvation, altered contractile protein expression, and cytoskeleton/microtubule derangements.8 In addition, defective myocyte handling of calcium also appears to be a central cause of both contractile dysfunction and arrhythmia development in heart failure. Several specific defects within the E-C coupling cascade have been detected (fig 3), but perhaps the most important of these is the observation that SR calcium stores are significantly reduced in heart failure.9 The intracellular Ca2+ transient required to initiate contraction is dependent on a sufficient SR calcium store and its subsequent release. When this store is depleted, SR calcium release will be curtailed, in terms of both its amplitude and duration, and as a result reduced contractile force is generated.10 The likely cause of this deficiency is a downregulation or reduced activity of SERCA,11 resulting in reduced loading of the SR with calcium. A further contributory factor may be upregulation of NCX,12 which also occurs in heart failure and may promote the removal of vital calcium from the cell. Reduced activity of RyR2 does not appear to be a significant factor in reduced SR calcium release; in fact there is evidence that RyR2 function may be augmented as a compensatory mechanism to overcome this deficiency.13 Over time, however, this would also serve to deplete further SR calcium stores regardless of any short term increase in calcium induced calcium release. Furthermore a diastolic leak of SR calcium (through RyR2 channels, the gating properties of which have been modified by phosphorylation) has been convincingly proposed as the mechanism whereby delayed afterdepolarisations, triggered ventricular arrhythmias, and sudden death in heart failure can occur.14,15 In addition, upregulation of NCX has also been shown to be a proarrhythmic phenomenon which facilitates the development of delayed afterdepolarisations and triggered arrhythmias in the failing heart.16
It is clear that any compensatory gain in cardiac E-C coupling mediated by adrenergic stimulation is ultimately unsuccessful in preventing the ongoing deterioration seen in untreated chronic heart failure. There is now direct evidence that in chronic heart failure, adrenergic stimulation and phosphorylation of RyR2 actually worsen cardiac function further instead of improving it. A series of experiments has shown that RyR2 becomes hyperphosphorylated in the failing heart and this leads to various functional deficiencies that increase the open probability of the channel and a tendency towards an unwanted leak of SR calcium, particularly during diastole.17 Such work is further supported by studies showing that oral β blocker treatment reverses the above functional deficits in RyR2 and prevents hyperphosphorylation of the channel.18,19 The precise beneficial action of β blockers in heart failure has never been adequately explained, bearing in mind their negative action on myocardial contraction in the non-failing heart. By inhibiting the excessive compensatory phosphorylation response on RyR2 in heart failure they are able to restore channel function. The gain in E-C coupling this allows is likely to contribute significantly towards their observed benefits on left ventricular function, as shown in recent trials. Furthermore by abolishing the specific diastolic leak of calcium through hyperphosphorylated RyR2 they remove the threat of arrhythmogenic delayed afterdepolarisations and are thus seen to have a valuable antiarrhythmic action in heart failure, preventing sudden arrhythmogenic death as well as improving contraction.
A further consistent experimental finding in myocytes taken from the failing heart is a functional uncoupling of the L type voltage dependent channels and their adjacent population of RyR2.20 As discussed above, the signal amplification this coupling normally allows is vital in mediating a sufficient Ca2+ transient for myocyte contraction. Without it, contraction is curtailed and this also contributes to the deteriorating inotropic state of the failing heart. One of the most likely mechanisms behind this uncoupling is a loss of the close spatial organisation between the two channels. In heart failure the extent of the sarcolemmal T tubule apparatus, which brings the L type channel into close proximity with RyR2, is reduced and this undoubtedly impairs the calcium induced calcium release amplification signal.21
A NEW DIRECTION IN INOTROPIC DRUG DEVELOPMENT
One of the main challenges facing drug developers today in the search for new compounds which influence the inotropic properties of the heart is to avoid any non-specific amplification of E-C coupling gain while at the same time addressing some of the specific functional deficits outlined above. At present circulating catecholamines and positive inotropic drugs, such as phosphodiesterase inhibitors and the various catecholamine analogues used in clinical practice, act on early steps in the signal cascade pathways that eventually mediate an increase in cardiac inotropy. At these early stages, amplified second messengers such as cyclic AMP not only act to increase cardiac inotropy but also feed into other intracellular metabolic pathways, all of which are energy consuming and increase myocardial workload. In this respect increasing cardiac inotropy through the use of such agents is highly inefficient and results in numerous unwanted intracellular consequences, which, in addition to increasing myocardial oxygen demand, are likely to contribute to the side effect profile of the agent.
What is needed in the future development of inotropic drugs are agents which specifically target the terminal effector mechanisms of the cell’s inotropic state, such as the myofilament proteins themselves and the components of E-C coupling outlined above. It is much more sensible to manipulate these targets than to rely on an indirect action brought about through an action many stages higher up in the signal amplification cascade. As our understanding of how these effector mechanisms function in both health and disease has improved, new specific therapeutic targets for drug development have emerged. In some cases drugs that have taken advantage of this increased understanding have already appeared. Levosimendan, for example, is a new class of calcium sensitising drug that acts directly on the myofilament protein apparatus, sensitising it to the stimulating actions of intracellular calcium.22 This drug, which has already shown promise in clinical trials of acute heart failure management,23,24 has emerged as a direct result of our greater understanding of the interaction between troponin and its activation by calcium. Following on from levosimendan, investigators are now looking again at the previously tarnished subject of positive inotropic drugs. Other E-C coupling components are emerging as credible specific targets for drug development, not only as a means of improving the inotropic state of the failing heart but also to address the problem of malignant ventricular arrhythmias in the context of heart failure.
THE EMERGING ROLE OF RYR2 AS A POTENTIAL TARGET FOR ANTIARRHYTHMIC TREATMENT
Pathological SR calcium leak, as a result of the functional deficiencies of RyR2 outlined above, appears to be an important proarrhythmic development in the failing heart, underlying delayed afterdepolarisations and the subsequent development of triggered ventricular arrhythmias. It has long been appreciated that intracellular calcium overload is a proarrhythmogenic condition and the probable cause of sudden death in patients with chronic heart failure whose mortality was increased by the use of positive inotropic drugs. The emerging causative role of RyR2 in this process offers an opportunity to address and modify such proarrhythmogenic conditions in an attempt to limit the development of fatal arrhythmias in patients with heart failure.
A greater understanding of the role played by E-C coupling components in arrhythmia generation will also come from the study of inherited arrhythmogenic disorders. Mutations in RyR2 have recently been identified as the cause of two rare inherited forms of ventricular arrhythmia and sudden cardiac death. These conditions—catecholaminergic polymorphic ventricular tachycardia25 and arrhythmogenic right ventricular dysplasia (subtype 2)26—are the first examples of a specific arrhythmogenic disorder occurring secondary to defective function of one of the main E-C coupling components outlined above. Functional analysis of these RyR2 mutations is beginning to emerge27 and should help in our understanding of how specific defects in RyR2 lead to cardiac arrhythmias. Not only will this benefit sufferers from these rare disorders but it may also yield useful information about the development and mechanisms behind RyR2 induced arrhythmias in heart failure.15 Delayed afterdepolarisations have already been shown to underlie arrhythmia generation in catecholaminergic ventricular tachycardia,28 and previous studies looking at the effects of pharmacological agents that induce delayed afterdepolarisations, such as cardiac glycosides, have established that they occur secondary to an SR calcium leak.29
These pieces of evidence in combination all point to a central defect in RyR2 function as the likely cause of delayed afterdepolarisation generation and subsequent triggered ventricular arrhythmias. If this association can be confirmed in ongoing studies, a novel target for antiarrhythmic drug treatment may well be emerging. Bearing in mind that 50% or more of ventricular tachycardias in both ischaemic and non-ischaemic cardiomyopathy are thought to be initiated by non-reentrant mechanisms such as delayed after depolarisations,30,31 the potential for an RyR2 antagonist drug that prevents proarrhythmic SR calcium leak is profound and may significantly advance the management of these arrhythmias. Although the emergence of such an agent is still some way off, drug development will be assisted by the numerous studies to date that have already used pharmacological modification of RyR2 to characterise its function and gating properties. The particular challenge for drug developers will be to produce a compound that reduces detrimental diastolic leakage of calcium through RyR2, while at the same time preserving or even amplifying the normal physiological release of calcium through RyR2 during early systole.
OTHER TARGETS FOR NEW THERAPEUTIC OPTIONS
The discovery that β blockers restore defective RyR2 function in the failing heart through a reversal of the hyperphosphorylated receptor state seen in this condition suggests that a specific antagonist of RyR2 phosphorylation may also be of benefit in the restoration of normal cardiac function. One particular effect of RyR2 hyperphosphorylation is to cause a dissociation of FK506 binding protein 12.6 (FKBP 12.6), an associated protein thought to have a role in the regulation of RyR2 gating and in orchestrating coupled gating between adjacent receptors.32 Its in vivo role has now been clarified by the development of FKBP 12.6 knock out mice which show increased duration and amplitude of Ca2+ sparks and an increased calcium induced calcium release gain.33 It appears that FKBP 12.6 serves to prevent excessive RyR2 opening and a subsequent detrimental SR calcium leak. FKBP 12.6 levels are known to be significantly reduced in heart failure models34 and this observation may in part explain the abnormal SR calcium leak observed in these models.35 Together, these results suggest that a decrease in FKBP 12.6 number or function is an important pathophysiological development in heart failure and arrhythmia pathogenesis. Pharmacological manipulation of this molecule, or its association with RyR2, may also be a potential avenue for the development of new drugs.
Another component of E-C coupling that has received attention for its potentially beneficial effects on the inotropic state of the heart is SERCA and its associated regulatory protein phospholamban.36 Phospholamban inhibits SERCA and thereby reduces the rate of calcium uptake into the SR. This inhibitory influence is removed when the protein is phosphorylated, and in theory restoring the function of downregulated SERCA in heart failure could be achieved by either decreasing the inhibitory influence of phospholamban or increasing the specific activity of SERCA itself. With regard to the former strategy, attempts have been made to reduce the expression levels of phospholamban through the use of specific antisense mRNA. This has the ability to reduce phospholamban expression levels by up to 70%37 and initial results on the subsequent gain in SERCA function that this facilitates are very encouraging. Pharmacological manipulation to overcome the negative influence of phospholamban is also possible in the laboratory, primarily through causing its dissociation from SERCA38,39; however, this approach has yet to generate a promising agent for clinical trials. With regard to increasing the specific activity of SERCA, two approaches have been used. Pharmacological stimulation of the pump itself is possible, with several compounds showing SERCA agonist activity in vitro.40,41 Such drug development is still confined to the laboratory and no specific agent has been put forward for large scale clinical trials. More novel and promising perhaps is the use of gene transfer techniques to increase the expression levels of SERCA as a direct action against its detrimental downregulation in heart failure. Studies using adenoviral mediated gene transfer in both animal models42 and isolated myocytes from failing human hearts43 have shown that this approach is capable of restoring impaired intracellular calcium handling and normalising contractile dysfunction. Ongoing work is expected to further clarify the potential of this technique.
The prospect of potential therapeutic developments with respect to other E-C coupling components is less encouraging. Upregulation of NCX in heart failure is believed to have negative side effects such as an increased risk of arrhythmias. No credible modification has yet emerged to restore normal myocardial function without unacceptable side effects. More work is needed to establish the precise role of NCX in contractile dysfunction and arrhythmogenesis before considering it as a potential therapeutic target.44 Similarly, the L type voltage dependent channel is unlikely to offer a new potential target for therapeutic manipulation. Calcium antagonist drugs acting on the L type channel are already in widespread use and have at best a neutral effect on myocardial inotropy. From the discussions above, an amplification of this channel’s function should have a positive inotropic action and would potentially help restore the defective coupling with RyR2. Any therapeutic modification which amplifies the inward Ca2+ transient runs the risk of intracellular calcium overload and cardiac arrhythmias. A more sensible strategy to restore the close functional link between these two channels would be to increase the sensitivity of RyR2 with respect to its activation by the depressed inward Ca2+ transient seen in heart failure.
The lack of emerging treatments which target the NCX and the L type channel highlight our ongoing need for further studies to clarify the role of these important sarcolemmal components, both under normal physiological conditions and in heart failure. As encouraging developments with regard to RyR2 and SERCA demonstrate, when a clear picture of how these proteins work emerges, subsequent opportunities for new treatment strategies soon follow. Although recent advances have been made in the treatment of heart failure and malignant ventricular arrhythmias, many patients remain symptomatic despite the use of β blockers, angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors, and other currently used treatments. Furthermore many patients are prevented from obtaining the potential benefits of such drugs owing to dose limiting side effects or contraindications to their use. Mechanical treatments such as left ventricular assist devices and implantable defibrillators are limited by their cost, and increasing road safety is reducing the availability of suitable hearts for heart transplant programmes. These practical points should not be forgotten, and with cardiovascular disease set to remain a major health care burden for the foreseeable future we will need new additional treatment strategies to complement those currently available. This will only emerge on the background of an increased understanding of the pathophysiological mechanisms underlying cardiac disease, and this in turn demands a greater awareness of the physiological processes that maintain normal cardiac structure and function. It remains to be seen whether any of the recent developments in our understanding of E-C coupling will eventually yield an effective pharmacological agent. What is clear from the advances and potential opportunities outlined in this article is that our negative experiences with positive inotropic drugs during the latter part of the last century should not stop us from continually searching for new and improved treatments based on the physiological processes that underlie the heart’s inotropic state.
We thank the British Heart Foundation for ongoing funding of the work in our department.