Table 3

Predictors for migraine improvement after PFO closure

Responders versus non-responders
RespondersNon-respondersp Values*
Patients11337
Age (years)51±11 (26–77)51±9 (29–68)0.84
Female50 (44%)69 (46%)0.57
Height (cm)172±8172±100.95
Weight (kg)75±1377±160.64
Body mass index (kg/m2)25.3±3.425.7±4.30.62
Atrial septal anatomy
 Left atrial size (mm)37±838±70.38
 PFO only69 (61%)21 (57%)0.70
 PFO and atrial septal aneurysm44 (39%)16 (43%)0.7
Right-to-left shunt
 Grade 13 (3%)2 (5%)0.6
 Grade 217 (15%)6 (16%)1
 Grade 393 (82%)29 (78%)0.63
Cardiovascular risk factors
 Arterial hypertension33 (29%)10 (27%)1
 Diabetes mellitus3 (3%)1 (3%)1
 Smoking history35 (31%)10 (27%)0.67
 Total cholesterol (mmol/l)5.3±1.15.0±0.80.12
Embolic index event
 Ischaemic stroke69 (61%)20 (54%)0.56
 Transient ischemic attack39 (35%)15 (41%)0.56
 Peripheral embolism5 (4%)2 (5%)1
Number of prior embolic events
 One76 (67%)30 (81%)0.14
 Two21 (19%)3 (8%)0.2
 Three5 (4%)1 (3%)0.1
 Four or more11 (10%)3 (8%)1
Migraine with aura78 (69%)18 (49%)0.03
Migraine characteristics
 Duration of symptoms (years)26±1427±140.71
 Frequency of migraine attacks
  <1 per month41 (36%)12 (32%)0.7
  1 per month36 (32%)12 (32%)1
  2–3 times per month8 (7%)4 (11%)0.49
  Once weekly24 (21%)6 (16%)0.64
  2–6 times per week2 (2%)1 (3%)1
  Once daily2 (2%)2 (6%)0.25
 Migraine duration
  <4 h36 (32%)11 (30%)1
  4–72 h71 (63%)24 (65%)1
  >72 h6 (5%)2 (5%)1
Migraine intensity (0–10)8±27±20.03
Inability to work during migraine attacks62 (55%)18 (49%)0.7
Patients taking any migraine medication104 (92%)31 (84%)0.33
  • * Responders versus non-responders.