Table 4

Secondary outcomes at O1 and O2

Control (n=41)Intervention (n=43)
O1O2O1O2
Palliative performance scale (%, SE)
 Ambulation79.6 (25.2)69.2 (33.4)82.2 (22.7)76.0 (28.4)
 Activity100.0 (0.0)100.0 (0.0)100.0 (0.0)100.0 (0.0)
 Self-care45.6 (44.1)30.8 (38.1)59.8 (42.7)40.5 (42.9)
 Intake90.0 (6.0)91.9 (5.2)91.9 (4.9)89.8 (6.2)
 Conscious level45.6 (44.1)30.8 (38.1)59.8 (42.7)40.5 (42.9)
 Overall65.5 (18.0)66.8 (18.9)64.72 (15.13)66.85 (18.67)
Edmonton Symptom Assessment System (%, SE)
 Pain51.5 (44.6)42.0 (43.9)63.1 (40.6)56.4 (44.0)
 Tiredness90.0 (7.0)91.6 (6.9)91.0 (6.3)89.8 (7.2)
 Nausea11.1 (9.4)10.8 (9.4)12.1 (10.1)9.1 (7.9)
 Depression70.9 (35.5)58.0 (42.2)65.1 (39.0)36.4 (33.5)**
 Anxiety75.5 (31.6)50.0 (43.1)70.0 (35.9)34.5 (38.8)**
 Drowsiness16.8 (17.2)14.4 (15.4)17.8 (18.0)9.1 (10.2)
 Loss of appetite87.6 (15.9)75.7 (27.4)82.2 (21.5)68.3 (31.9)
 Sense of well-being90.0 (9.2)89.2 (10.0)89.0 (9.9)85.7 (12.5)
 Dyspnoea83.2 (20.3)81.1 (22.5)85.2 (18.3)71.0 (30.0)
 Total35.13 (2.15)32.39 (3.20)33.32 (1.93)23.97 (2.20)***
Chronic Heart Failure Questionnaire (score, SE)
 Dyspnoea**4.83 (0.18)4.89 (0.28)4.65 (0.17)5.82 (0.19)***
 Fatigue3.64 (0.20)3.77 (0.24)3.80 (0.20)4.19 (0.26)
 Emotional**4.86 (0.24)4.61 (0.29)5.09 (0.19)5.68 (0.17)**
 Mastery**4.58 (0.22)4.64 (0.26)4.30 (0.22)5.36 (0.22)***
 Total**4.49 (0.15)4.47 (0.23)4.45 (0.14)5.26 (0.17)***
McGill Quality of Life Questionnaire (score, SE)
 Physical4.07 (0.25)4.79 (0.33)*4.48 (0.25)5.72 (0.35)***
 Psychological*7.63 (0.33)7.71 (0.48)7.82 (0.30)9.06 (0.23)***
 Existential5.61 (0.45)5.86 (0.50)6.01 (0.38)7.17 (0.35)**
 Support*8.05 (0.30)7.82 (0.39)7.87 (0.32)8.57 (0.25)*
 Overall*6.33 (0.33)6.16 (0.44)6.41 (0.32)7.37 (0.29)*
 Total*6.35 (0.23)6.46 (0.36)6.51 (0.22)7.57 (0.21)***
Satisfaction with care (score, SE)***N/A36.55 (2.09)N/A48.84 (1.82)
  • Tests using generalised estimating equation (GEE); *p<0.05; ** p<0.01; ***p<0.001.