Table 4

The results of seasonal multivariable analyses for OHCA using the generalised additive model with cubic splines, 2012–2016

TimeOHCASummerWinterSpring and autumn
βt-valueRRER (%)95% CIβt-valueRRER
(%)
95% CIβt-valueRRER (%)95% CI
Lag 0Average temperature−0.007−1.770.9929−0.71(0.9850 to 1.0007)−0.032−16.900.9678−3.22(0.9640 to 0.9714)0.0112.391.01151.15(1.0020 to 1.0210)
Humidity−0.023−19.840.9769−2.31(0.9746 to 0.9791)−0.002−3.220.9980−0.20(0.9967 to 0.9992)−0.020−9.200.9798−2.02(0.9755 to 0.9840)
Daily range0.0518.881.05235.23(1.0404 to 1.0643)0.0071.991.00750.75(1.0404 to 1.0643)0.0761.311.07997.99(0.9628 to 1.2111)
PM2.5 0.01821.421.01891.89(1.0171 to 1.0206)0.01423.061.01461.46(1.0133 to 1.0158)0.02211.761.02322.32(1.0193 to 1.0271)
Lag 1Average temperature−0.011−2.740.9887−1.13(0.9806 to 0.9967)−0.032−16.400.9682−3.18(0.9645 to 0.9719)−0.006−1.020.9939−0.61(0.9822 to 1.0056)
Humidity−0.024−21.160.9754−2.46(0.9731 to 0.9776)−0.001−3.060.9980−0.20(0.9967 to 0.9992)−0.020−7.870.9801−1.99(0.9752 to 0.9850)
Daily range0.06210.551.06426.42(1.0519 to 1.0765)0.0041.181.00460.46(0.9969 to 1.0123)0.0121.861.01261.26(0.9993 to 1.0261)
PM2.5 0.01921.741.01941.94(1.0176 to 1.0211)0.01522.641.01531.53(1.0140 to 1.0167)0.0229.211.02272.27(1.0178 to 1.0275)
Lag 2Average temperature−0.010−2.550.9896−1.04(0.9816 to 0.9975)−0.032−16.600.9675−3.25(0.9637 to 0.9713)0.0000.111.00060.06(0.9899 to 1.0114)
Humidity−0.024−21.010.9757−2.43(0.9735 to 0.9779)−0.002−4.000.9974−0.26(0.9961 to 0.9986)−0.019−7.860.9810−1.90(0.9763 to 0.9857)
Daily range0.0589.971.06006.00(1.0479 to 1.0722)0.0082.051.00810.81(1.0003 to 1.0158)0.0600.951.06276.27(0.9377 to 1.2042)
PM2.5 0.01820.861.01841.84(1.0152 to 1.0197)0.01523.201.01551.55(1.0142 to 1.0168)0.02511.431.02572.57(1.0212 to 1.0302)
Lag 3Average temperature−0.010−2.620.9892−1.08(0.9812 to 0.9972)−0.033−16.540.9673−3.27(0.9634 to 0.9711)0.0020.431.00260.26(0.9908 to 1.0145)
Humidity−0.024−20.870.9754−2.46(0.9731 to 0.9777)−0.002−4.240.9973−0.27(0.9960 to 0.9985)−0.009−3.870.9905−0.95(0.9857 to 0.9953)
Daily range0.06210.621.06486.48(1.0525 to 1.0772)0.0061.541.00600.60(0.9983 to 1.0137)0.0274.261.02742.74(1.0147 to 1.0403)
PM2.5 0.01821.601.01911.91(1.0173 to 1.0208)0.01421.511.01431.43(1.0129 to 1.0155)0.02110.391.02202.20(1.0178 to 1.0262)
Lag 4Average temperature−0.003−0.650.9968−0.32(0.9870 to 1.0065)−0.035−13.520.9648−3.52(0.9600 to 0.9695)−0.009−8.320.9908−0.92(0.9886 to 0.9929)
Humidity−0.014−9.960.9858−1.42(0.9830 to 0.9885)0.0000.041.00040.04(0.9987 to 1.0020)−0.008−17.900.9916−0.84(0.9907 to 0.9925)
Daily range0.013−1.961.01361.36(1.0000 to 1.0274)0.0070.751.00750.75(0.9980 to 1.0171)0.03512.881.03573.57(1.0302 to 1.0412)
PM2.5 0.0011.331.00140.14(0.9993 to 1.0034)0.0020.231.00230.23(1.0007 to 1.0038)0.0024.111.00260.26(1.0013 to 1.0038)
Lag 5Average temperature0.0040.891.00440.44(0.9946 to 1.0143)−0.035−14.160.9652−3.48(0.9605 to 0.9699)−0.010−9.160.9900−1.00(0.9878 to 0.9921)
Humidity−0.013−9.320.9867−1.33(0.9839 to 0.9894)0.0011.591.00130.13(0.9996 to 1.0029)−0.007−16.570.9923−0.77(0.9913 to 0.9932)
Daily range0.0020.301.00200.20(0.9890 to 1.0151)0.0030.801.00380.38(0.9945 to 1.0131)0.03111.611.03163.16(1.0261 to 1.0370)
PM2.5 0.0000.961.00100.10(0.9989 to 1.0029)0.0023.831.00280.28(1.0013 to 1.0042)0.0012.131.00130.13(1.0001 to 1.0025)
Lag 6Average temperature0.0020.671.00200.20(0.9922 to 1.0118)−0.032−13.150.9680−3.20(0.9632 to 0.9727)−0.009−8.410.9908−0.92(0.9886 to 0.9929)
Humidity−0.009−8.740.9910−0.90(0.9882 to 0.9938)0.0011.631.00140.14(0.9997 to 1.0030)−0.007−16.530.9924−0.76(0.9915 to 0.9933)
Daily range0.0010.281.00100.10(0.9880 to 1.0141)0.0061.311.00630.63(0.9968 to 1.0158)0.03212.181.03283.28(1.0274 to 1.0381)
PM2.5 0.0000.661.00000.00(0.9980 to 1.0020)0.0034.441.00330.33(1.0018 to 1.0047)0.0013.061.00190.19(1.0006 to 1.0031)
  • Summer (May–August), winter (December–February) and spring and autumn (March–May and September–November, respectively).

  • ER, excess risk; OHCA, out-of-hospital cardiac arrest; PM2.5, particulate matter ≤2 µm; RR, relative risk.