Table 3

Studies reporting heart failure mortality identified in systematic review

StudyLocationDiagnostic criteriaSettingAge range
Central Europe, Eastern Europe and Central Asia Kaplon-Cieslicka, 2016PolandESC 2012 criteriaPolish cohort of ESC registry18+
Ozieranski, 2016PolandESC 2012 criteriaPolish cohort of ESC registry18+
Parenica, 2013CzechiaSigns and symptomsPatients from participating hospitals
High-income Canepa, 2019ItalySigns and symptomsRandomised nested trial (GISSI-HF)
Chen, 2019SwedenICD-10 codesSwedish Heart Failure Registry
Stork, 2017GermanyICD-10 codesInsurance records
Nakano, 2016DenmarkICD-10 codesNational healthcare records (DHFR)18+
Schmidt, 2016DenmarkICD-8 and ICD-10 codesHospital discharges, death registry
Staszewsky, 2016Lombardy, ItalyChart extractionLinked healthcare databases
Atzema, 2015CanadaICD-10 codesCitizen registrar, healthcare databases
Berkovitch, 2015IsraelSigns and symptomsSurvey of patients in 25 hospitals
Coles, 2015Massachusetts, USAFramingham criteriaPatients in 11 contributing centres18+
Ohlmeier, 2015GermanyICD-10 codesInsurance records
Vanhercke, 2015BelgiumESC 2015 criteriaPatients in participating hospitals18+
Barasa, 2014SwedenICD-9 and ICD-10 codesHospital discharges, death registry18–84
Corrao, 2014Lombardy, ItalyICD-9 codesHealth services database
Sartipy, 2014SwedenICD-10 codesSwedish Heart Failure Registry
Tuppin, 2014FranceICD-10 codesInsurance records
Chamberlain, 2013Minnesota, USAFramingham criteriaElectronic medical records
Hoekstra, 2013The NetherlandsESC 2008 criteriaPatients in 17 participating hospitals18+
Lassus, 2013FinlandSigns and symptomsPatients from participating hospitals
Maison, 2013FranceWHO classificationPatients from participating hospitals
McAlister, 2013Alberta, CanadaICD-9 and ICD-10 codesLinked healthcare registries18+
McManus, 2013Massachusetts, USAFramingham criteriaPatients from participating hospitals18+
Nakano, 2013DenmarkICD-10 codesNational healthcare records (DHFR)18+
Oster, 2013IsraelSigns and symptomsPatients from participating hospitals
Chen, 2011USAICD-9 codesReview of Medicare claims data (CMS)65+
Ezekowitz, 2011Alberta, CanadaICD-9 and ICD-10 codesLinked healthcare registries
Gamble, 2011Alberta, CanadaICD-9 and ICD-10 codesLinked healthcare registries
Goda, 2010Tokyo, JapanSigns and symptomsPatients in referral hospital
Novack, 2010IsraelICD-9 codesPatients from participating hospitals
Tribouilloy, 2010FranceFramingham and ESC 1995 criteriaPatients from participating hospitals20+
Wasywich, 2010New ZealandICD-9 codesPublic health system database18+
Jhund, 2009ScotlandICD-9 and ICD-10 codesHospital discharges, death registry
Amsalem, 2008IsraelSigns and symptomsHeart Failure Survey in Israel database
Ko, 2008Ontario, CanadaFramingham criteriaRecords from participating hospitals20–105
Shiba, 2008JapanSigns and symptomsPatients in participating hospitals (CHART-1)18+
Ammar, 2007Minnesota, USAFramingham criteriaRandom sample of county45+
Rathore, 2006USAICD-9 codesSample of Medicare beneficiaries65+
van Jaarsveld, 2006Northern NetherlandsICPC codesSample from participating GPs57+
Bleumink, 2004Rotterdam, The NetherlandsESC 2001 criteriaCohort study of single suburb55+
Lee, 2004Ontario, CanadaICD-9 codesHospital discharges, death registry65+
Shahar, 2004Minnesota, USAICD-9 codesPatients in participating counties35–84
Sosin, 2004UKESC 2001 criteriaPatients in participating hospitals
Lee, 2003Ontario, CanadaICD-9 codesPatients from participating hospitals
Cowie, 2000West London, EnglandAdapted ESC 1995 criteriaPatients in district hospital
Heller, 2000South Wales, AustraliaICD-9 and ICD-10 codesPatients in 22 hospitals (Heart and Stroke Register)
Tsuchihashi, 2000JapanFramingham criteriaPatients from participating hospitals
Alexander, 1999California, USAICD-9 codesReview of CA hospital discharges
Latin America and Caribbean Gioli-Pereira, 2019Sao Paulo, BrazilSigns and symptomsPatients from a single practice18–80
Lalljie, 2007JamaicaFramingham criteriaPatients from a single practice
AHRI, 2013IndiaESC 2012 criteriaPatients from participating hospitals
South Asia SCTIMST, 2006IndiaESC 1995 criteriaPatients from participating hospitals
SCTIMST, 2001IndiaESC 1995 criteriaPatients from participating hospitals
Southeast Asia, East Asia and Oceania Lyu, 2019ChinaBoston criteriaPatients from participating hospitals18+
Hai, 2016Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of ChinaFramingham criteriaPatients from a single hospital18+
Hung, 2000ChinaICD-9 codesPatients in 11 participating hospitals
Sub-Saharan Africa Makubi, 2016United Republic of TanzaniaFramingham criteriaPatients from referral hospital18+
  • CHART, Chronic Heart Failure Analysis and Registry in the Tohoku District; CMS, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services; DHFR, Danish Heart Failure Registry; ESC, European Society of Cardiology; GISSI-HF, Gruppo Italiano per lo Studio della Streptochinasi nell'Infarto Miocardico-Heart Failure; GP, general practitioner.