Scoring of five options by 13 topic experts
| Option score median values (range) | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Benefit criteria | Status quo | Enhanced routine data | Community epidemiology model | Australian cardiovascular disease model | CHD registry |
| Hospital activity | 50 (30 to 80) | 70 (50 to 90) | 75 (40 to 90) | 65 (45 to 85) | 80 (35 to 90) |
| Primary care activity | 20 ( 5 to 40) | 40 ( 7 to 60) | 60 (30 to 80) | 50 (20 to 85) | 40 (20 to 80) |
| Prescribing | 30 (20 to 90) | 50 (30 to 91) | 70 (40 to 92) | 55 (30 to 92) | 60 (35 to 95) |
| Socioeconomic impact | 10 ( 2 to 20) | 10 ( 2 to 50) | 10 ( 2 to 70) | 10 ( 2 to 70) | 10 ( 2 to 60) |
| Risk factors | 50 (20 to 80) | 50 (25 to 80) | 70 (35 to 90) | 60 (30 to 85) | 60 (25 to 80) |
| Prevalence | 40 (10 to 70) | 55 (30 to 80) | 70 (50 to 90) | 58 (30 to 85) | 60 (20 to 95) |
| Incidence | 40 ( 5 to 70) | 52 (25 to 75) | 70 (40 to 90) | 52 (15 to 85) | 51 (20 to 95) |
| Case registration | 30 ( 5 to 60) | 40 (25 to 65) | 60 (25 to 95) | 50 (25 to 80) | 50 (20 to 90) |
| Mortality rates and case fatality | 55 (20 to 80) | 65 (30 to 80) | 80 (50 to 90) | 65 (40 to 90) | 65 (42 to 95) |
| Patient function | 5 ( 0 to 10) | 50 (20 to 80) | 70 (30 to 85) | 50 (20 to 80) | 5 ( 0 to 10) |
| Quality of life | 5 ( 0 to 10) | 50 (20 to 80) | 70 (30 to 90) | 10 ( 0 to 50) | 10 ( 0 to 40) |
| Compatibility for international comparisons | 50 (25 to 90) | 50 (25 to 90) | 70 (50 to 95) | 65 (40 to 95) | 55 (35 to 90) |
| Breadth of coverage | 60 (35 to 85) | 60 (40 to 85) | 70 (55 to 95) | 70 (50 to 95) | 65 (50 to 90) |
| Frequency | 60 (25 to 75) | 60 (25 to 85) | 70 (63 to 90) | 70 (50 to 80) | 65 (35 to 90) |